Lesson 3 of 8 · 16 min
The information processing approach and Sternberg's triarchic theory
Describe how the information processing approach and Sternberg's triarchic theory explain intelligence, and compare each with the psychometric approach.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the information processing approach to intelligence, including speed of processing and working memory.
- Describe the analytical, creative and practical parts of Sternberg's triarchic theory.
- Compare each approach with the psychometric approach, with strengths and limitations.
- Interpret a correlation between inspection time and a reasoning test.
The psychometric approach tells you how much a person scores, but not how they solve a problem. The two approaches in this lesson ask different questions. The information processing approach asks what the mind is doing, step by step, when it reasons. Sternberg asks what intelligence is for in a person's life.
The information processing approach
This approach borrows a metaphor from computing. Information comes in through the senses, is held and worked on in working memory, is stored in and retrieved from long-term memory, and leads to a response. On this view, a more intelligent person carries out these processes faster and more efficiently.
Definition
The information processing approach
The information processing approach explains intelligence by how quickly and efficiently a person takes in, stores, retrieves and manipulates information.
Researchers measure the processes directly rather than a total score:
- Reaction time: how quickly a person presses the right button when a light comes on (simple reaction time) or when one of several lights comes on (choice reaction time).
- Inspection time: the shortest time two lines must be shown, before a mask covers them, for the person to say reliably which line is longer. It measures speed of taking in information, with no need to respond quickly.
- Working memory capacity: how much a person can hold in mind and work on at once, as in a backwards digit span.
- Strategies: how a person plans, checks and changes their approach to a problem (sometimes called metacognition).
People with shorter inspection times and faster choice reaction times tend to score higher on IQ tests, but the correlations are only weak to moderate: reviews put the inspection time correlation at around , or about once measurement error is allowed for.
Sample class data (illustrative): 14 students' inspection times against their score on a matrices reasoning test. Shorter inspection time goes with higher scores.
Worked example
Interpret a correlation between inspection time and reasoning
To test the information processing approach, a Year 11 class measured each of 14 students' inspection time (in milliseconds) and their score out of 36 on a matrices reasoning test. A calculator gave Pearson's and (illustrative class data).
(a) Name the type of investigation and its variables. (b) Write the null and alternative hypotheses. (c) Interpret the result, and state one limitation of the conclusion.
Step 1: Identify the design
Nothing was manipulated: the class measured two variables as they naturally occur. This is correlational research with two co-variables, inspection time and matrices score.
Step 2: Write the hypotheses
: there is no correlation between inspection time and matrices score in the population. : there is a correlation between inspection time and matrices score.
Step 3: Describe r
is a moderate negative correlation: students with shorter inspection times (faster processing) tended to score higher.
Step 4: Decide on significance
, so reject : the correlation is statistically significant.
A p-value below 0.05 means a correlation this strong would be unlikely if there were really no relationship in the population.
Step 5: State a limitation
The study is correlational, so it cannot show that faster processing causes higher reasoning scores; a third variable, such as attention or motivation on the day, could affect both. The sample is also small (14) and a convenience sample of one class, so it may not generalise.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Correlational; co-variables inspection time and matrices score. (b) : no correlation; : a correlation. (c) A moderate negative correlation, significant at , supporting the link between processing speed and reasoning; but it does not show cause, and 14 students from one class may not represent the population.
Method
Design: was anything manipulated? If not, correlational.
Describe r: direction and strength.
Compare p with 0.05 and decide about .
Limit the conclusion: cause, sample, measurement.
Watch out for
Calling inspection time the independent variable. In a correlational study there are co-variables, not an IV and DV.
Concluding that faster processing causes higher intelligence.
A study finds a correlation of between inspection time and IQ. Which conclusion is justified?
Strengths
- Explains how people solve problems, not only how well.
- Measures such as reaction time are objective and measured in milliseconds, a ratio scale.
- Some tasks need little vocabulary or school knowledge.
- Links intelligence to research on attention, memory and the brain.
Limitations
- The correlations with IQ are weak to moderate, so speed explains only part of the differences between people.
- The evidence is correlational: speed may not cause intelligence.
- Simple laboratory tasks are far from everyday problems (low ecological validity).
- Not every culture treats speed as a sign of intelligence.
- Says little about creativity, practical skill or emotions.
Sternberg's triarchic theory
Robert Sternberg (1985) argued that IQ tests capture only one part of intelligence: the part that helps you at school. He defined intelligence as what lets you succeed in your own life and setting, and divided it into three parts ("triarchic" means rule by three).
| Part | Also called | What it is | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Analytical | Componential | Analysing, comparing, judging and evaluating; the mental processes behind solving a problem | Working out which argument in an essay question is strongest |
| Creative | Experiential | Dealing with new situations and inventing new ideas, and making familiar tasks automatic | Designing a new way to raise money for a club |
| Practical | Contextual | Adapting to your environment, shaping it to suit you, or choosing a better one: "street smarts" | Working out how to get a casual job and keep a manager happy |
Open each approach to see what it counts as intelligence and how it would be assessed.
Classify each ability under the part of Sternberg's triarchic theory it shows best.
Sternberg built tests to match, such as the Sternberg Triarchic Abilities Test, with items for each part, and he measured practical intelligence through tacit knowledge: the unwritten know-how of a job, such as how to manage your time as a junior manager.
Strengths
- Broader than IQ: includes creativity and practical success, which matter in work and life.
- Defines intelligence by success in a person's own context, so it allows for different cultures and settings.
- Analytical, creative and practical scores together predict some outcomes better than analytical scores alone.
Limitations
- The three parts are hard to measure reliably; creative and practical tasks need judgement to score.
- Analytical, creative and practical scores correlate with one another and with g, so they may not be separate abilities.
- Less research supports it than the psychometric approach, and its tests are not as widely standardised.
Exam tip
Compare, do not just describe
A comparison question wants each point set against the psychometric approach: "Unlike IQ tests, which measure mainly analytical ability, Sternberg's theory also counts creative and practical intelligence, so…". Use words such as whereas, unlike and both.
| Feature | Psychometric | Information processing | Triarchic |
|---|---|---|---|
| What intelligence is | A general ability (g) plus broad abilities, measured as IQ | Speed and efficiency of mental processes | Analytical, creative and practical abilities that bring success in your context |
| How it is measured | Standardised IQ tests with norms | Reaction time, inspection time, working memory tasks | Triarchic tests, tacit knowledge measures |
| Main strength | Reliable, standardised, predicts school results | Objective measures; explains how | Broad; allows for context |
| Main limitation | Narrow; can be culturally biased | Moderate correlations; lab tasks | Hard to measure; parts overlap with g |
Summary
The information processing approach explains intelligence by the speed and efficiency of taking in, storing, retrieving and manipulating information.
Faster inspection and reaction times correlate weakly to moderately with higher IQ, but correlation does not show cause.
Sternberg's triarchic theory has three parts: analytical (componential), creative (experiential) and practical (contextual).
Sternberg broadens intelligence to success in one's own context, but his three abilities are hard to measure and overlap with g.
Compare each approach with the psychometric one: what it counts as intelligence, how it measures it, and its strengths and limitations.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.