Lesson 4 of 8 · 18 min
Gardner's multiple intelligences, Goleman's EQ and the uses of IQ
Describe Gardner's multiple intelligences and Goleman's emotional intelligence, and discuss the significance of the common uses of IQ testing compared with all four other approaches.
What you will be able to do
- Describe Gardner's eight intelligences and the evidence he used to identify them.
- Describe Goleman's five components of emotional intelligence and how EQ is measured.
- Discuss the significance of the common uses of the psychometric approach (education, diagnosis, selection, research) compared with the other approaches.
A gifted cellist, an elite netballer and a counsellor who always knows what to say might all score close to 100 on an IQ test. Two theorists argued that the test is missing what makes them remarkable.
Gardner's multiple intelligences
Howard Gardner (1983) proposed that there is no single intelligence but several relatively independent ones. A person can be strong in one and ordinary in another. He began with seven and added an eighth, naturalist, in 1999.
| Intelligence | Ability to… | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Linguistic | use language: reading, writing, explaining, persuading | A journalist, a poet |
| Logical-mathematical | reason logically, work with numbers and abstract patterns | A scientist, a programmer |
| Spatial | picture and manipulate objects and spaces in the mind | An architect, a navigator |
| Musical | perceive, remember and create pitch, rhythm and melody | A composer, a didgeridoo player |
| Bodily-kinaesthetic | use the body skilfully and handle objects | A dancer, a surgeon, an athlete |
| Interpersonal | understand other people's moods, motives and intentions | A teacher, a negotiator |
| Intrapersonal | understand your own feelings, strengths and goals | Anyone who reflects well on themselves |
| Naturalist (1999) | recognise and classify plants, animals and patterns in nature | A ranger, a botanist |
Gardner did not simply list talents. He accepted an ability as an intelligence only if it met criteria, among them:
- Brain evidence: damage to one area can destroy one ability while sparing others (a stroke that removes speech but leaves musical ability).
- Exceptional individuals: savants and prodigies who are outstanding in one ability and ordinary or impaired in others.
- Its own development: a typical course from novice to expert.
- A symbol system: such as written music, numerals or language.
Open Gardner's theory and compare it with the others, then sort each way of assessing intelligence into the approach that would use it.
Strengths
- Values abilities that IQ tests leave out, such as music, movement and understanding people.
- Draws on evidence from the brain, savants and development.
- Widely used by teachers to plan varied lessons and to recognise more students' strengths.
Limitations
- Little experimental evidence: Gardner did not develop standardised tests, so the intelligences are hard to measure reliably.
- When they are measured, several (linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial) correlate with one another and with g, so they may not be independent.
- Critics argue that musical and bodily-kinaesthetic abilities are talents, not intelligences.
- Often misused as "learning styles", which Gardner himself rejects.
Common mistake
Multiple intelligences are not learning styles
Gardner's theory says people differ in abilities. It does not say that a "musical learner" learns maths best through song. Research does not support teaching to learning styles, and Gardner has said himself that the two ideas are different.
Goleman's emotional intelligence
The term emotional intelligence was coined by Peter Salovey and John Mayer (1990). The journalist and psychologist Daniel Goleman made it famous with his book Emotional Intelligence (1995), which claimed that emotional skills can matter as much as IQ for success at work and in relationships. A score on a measure of emotional intelligence is often called EQ, by analogy with IQ.
Definition
Emotional intelligence (EQ)
Emotional intelligence is the ability to recognise, understand and manage your own emotions, and to recognise and respond well to other people's.
| Component | What it involves |
|---|---|
| Self-awareness | Knowing what you are feeling and why, and how your feelings affect you |
| Self-regulation | Managing your emotions and impulses: calming down, thinking before acting |
| Motivation | Using emotions to pursue goals: persistence, optimism, delaying gratification |
| Empathy | Recognising and understanding other people's emotions |
| Social skills | Managing relationships: communicating, resolving conflict, leading, cooperating |
EQ is measured in two main ways. Self-report questionnaires ask people to rate statements such as "I can usually tell how I am feeling". Ability tests ask people to solve emotional problems, such as identifying the emotion in a face or choosing the best way to handle a tense situation, and compare the answers with experts' or the majority's. The next lessons judge how reliable and valid both kinds are.
Match each behaviour to the component of Goleman's emotional intelligence it shows best.
Strengths
- Recognises that managing emotions and relationships matters for success, which IQ tests ignore.
- Its skills can be taught, so it is used in school wellbeing programs and leadership training.
- Ability measures of EI predict some outcomes, such as the quality of relationships, a little beyond IQ and personality.
Limitations
- Goleman's model is broad: motivation and social skills overlap with personality traits rather than abilities.
- Self-report EQ measures depend on honest self-insight and are easy to fake, for example in a job application.
- Goleman's strongest claims, that EQ matters more than IQ, were not backed by published research when he made them.
The significance of the uses of IQ testing
The syllabus asks you to discuss why the psychometric approach matters in practice, compared with the other four. IQ tests are used for decisions that change lives, so their significance is real, and so are the risks.
| Use | What IQ testing contributes | What the other approaches add or warn |
|---|---|---|
| Education: identifying students who need extra support or extension | A standardised measure that predicts school results (correlation about 0.5) and shows a profile of strengths and weaknesses | Gardner and Sternberg warn that students strong in creative, practical, musical or interpersonal ability can be overlooked |
| Clinical diagnosis: intellectual disability, effects of brain injury or dementia | Index scores pinpoint which abilities are affected; norms show how unusual a score is | Information processing measures such as processing speed help track change; adaptive functioning must be assessed as well |
| Employment: selecting staff | Ability tests predict job training success and performance | Goleman argues EQ predicts leadership and teamwork; Sternberg that tacit knowledge predicts managerial success; both raise questions of fairness |
| Research: studying development, ageing and inheritance | A reliable, comparable number across studies and countries | The other approaches ask why and how people differ, not only by how much |
The psychometric approach dominates these uses because its tests are standardised, reliable and predictive, and no other approach has measures as well developed. Its significance is also its danger: a single number can be over-trusted, can label a child, and can be unfair to people the norms do not represent. The other approaches matter mostly because they remind users what an IQ leaves out.
Worked example
Discuss using IQ alone to select team leaders
A retail company plans to choose its new customer service team leaders using only the applicants' scores on a 30-minute IQ test.
Discuss the significance of using the psychometric approach for this purpose, compared with Goleman's emotional intelligence and Sternberg's triarchic theory. (6 marks)
Step 1: State what the psychometric approach offers
An IQ test is standardised, scored the same way for everyone and highly reliable, and ability scores predict success in job training and performance moderately well. That makes it a fair-seeming, cheap and defensible first measure.
Step 2: State its limitation for this job
It samples mainly analytical, school-type abilities. A team leader in customer service also needs to manage their own frustration, read customers' and staff members' emotions and resolve conflict, which an IQ test does not measure (limited content validity for the job).
Step 3: Bring in Goleman
Goleman's emotional intelligence targets exactly those skills: self-regulation, empathy and social skills. But self-report EQ measures are easy to fake in a job application and overlap with personality, so they should not be used alone either.
Step 4: Bring in Sternberg
Sternberg's practical intelligence (tacit knowledge of how to get things done in a workplace) is relevant too, and could be assessed with realistic scenarios, though such measures are harder to score reliably.
Step 5: Judge
The psychometric approach is significant because it gives a reliable, standardised measure, but on its own it would miss abilities central to the job. A better process combines an ability test with structured assessments of emotional and practical skills, such as interviews and work scenarios.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
IQ testing is significant because it is standardised, reliable and moderately predictive of job performance, but for a team-leader role it misses the emotional (Goleman) and practical (Sternberg) abilities the job needs. Those approaches add relevant abilities but have weaker measures, so the company should combine methods rather than rely on IQ alone.
Method
State the strength of the psychometric approach for the use.
State what it misses for this use.
Compare each other approach: what it adds, and its own weakness.
Finish with a judgement.
Watch out for
Describing each theory without relating it to the job.
Saying EQ "is more important than IQ" without evidence.
A school wants a measure of intelligence for placing Year 7 students into extension maths that is standardised, has Australian norms and can be scored the same way for everyone. Which approach best meets those needs?
Exam tip
Discussing significance
For "discuss the significance of the uses…", name a use, say what IQ testing contributes to it and why that is valued (standardised, reliable, predictive), then set it against another approach and say what it adds or warns. Finish with a judgement: IQ testing is significant because…, but…
Summary
Gardner (1983, 1999) proposed eight relatively independent intelligences, identified by brain evidence, exceptional individuals, development and symbol systems.
Multiple intelligences are hard to measure, several correlate with g, and they are not learning styles.
Goleman's (1995) emotional intelligence has five components: self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy and social skills.
EQ is measured by self-report questionnaires or ability tests; Goleman's broad model overlaps with personality and his strongest claims outran the evidence.
IQ testing is used in education, clinical diagnosis, employment and research because it is standardised, reliable and predictive; the other approaches show what a single score leaves out.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.