Lesson 1 of 10 · 15 min
Mind versus body, and psychology as a science
Discuss the mind-versus-body problem through Galen's materialist approach and Descartes' dualistic approach, and see how psychology tests ideas about the mind with evidence.
What you will be able to do
- Explain what the mind-versus-body problem asks.
- Describe Galen's materialist approach and Descartes' dualistic approach, with the reasoning behind each.
- Compare the two approaches and explain why the materialist approach can be tested with evidence.
- Outline how psychology investigates questions scientifically.
Decide to raise your hand, then raise it. Something non-physical seemed to happen first (a decision, an intention) and then something physical (muscles contracting). How does a thought move an arm? Is the decision something your brain does, or something your mind does to your brain?
That is the mind-versus-body problem: how are the mind (thoughts, feelings, memories, consciousness) and the body, especially the brain, related? It is the oldest question in psychology, and the answer the discipline works from shapes everything else in this course.
Definition
Psychology
Psychology is the scientific study of the mind and behaviour. Behaviour is what a person does that can be observed and measured, such as speaking or reacting to a sound. Mental processes (thinking, remembering, feeling) cannot be observed directly, so psychologists infer them from behaviour and from measures of the body and brain.
There are two broad answers to the mind-versus-body problem. The syllabus asks you to know each through one historical figure.
History
Claudius Galen (about 129 to 216 CE)
Galen was a Greek physician who worked in Pergamon, where he treated injured gladiators, and later in Rome. Many thinkers before him, including Aristotle, had placed the mind in the heart. Galen argued from evidence that it was in the brain:
- Head injuries in his patients changed their thinking, sensation and movement; injuries elsewhere did not.
- Dissecting animals, he traced the nerves from the sense organs and muscles to the brain and spinal cord.
- In a public demonstration he cut nerves in the neck of a live, squealing pig. The pig stopped squealing but kept struggling: the nerves carried the brain's control of the voice.
Galen also explained temperament with the body's four humours (blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile): too much black bile, for example, made a person melancholic. For Galen, mental life had physical causes in the body.
Key idea
The materialist approach
The mind is produced by the physical body, so mental processes can be explained by the brain and its processes. There is only one kind of thing, the physical, and the mind is what the brain does. Galen held an early version: mental functions were located in the brain and influenced by the body's humours.
History
René Descartes (1596 to 1650)
Descartes was a French philosopher and mathematician. He argued that he could doubt everything about his body, but not that he was thinking: "I think, therefore I am." So the mind, he concluded, is a different kind of thing from the body.
- The mind is non-physical: it thinks, doubts, wills and feels, and takes up no space.
- The body is physical: a machine that works by mechanical principles, like the water-driven moving statues in the royal gardens of his time. Reflexes, digestion and breathing need no mind at all.
- The two interact in the pineal gland, a small structure deep in the brain. Descartes chose it because it is single (most brain structures come in pairs) and sits near the centre of the brain.
The pineal gland, which Descartes proposed as the place where mind and body interact. Today it is known to release melatonin, which helps regulate sleep.
Key idea
The dualistic approach
The mind and the body are two separate kinds of thing: a non-physical mind and a physical body that interact. Descartes held that they interact through the pineal gland.
Which statement describes the dualistic approach to the mind-versus-body problem?
Materialist (Galen)
- One kind of thing: the physical body.
- The mind is what the brain does.
- Mental changes have physical causes: brain injuries, humours.
- Predicts that changing the brain changes the mind, so it can be tested.
Dualistic (Descartes)
- Two kinds of thing: a non-physical mind and a physical body.
- They interact through the pineal gland.
- The body is a machine; the mind thinks and wills.
- Cannot say how something non-physical moves something physical, and a non-physical mind cannot be measured.
Weighing the two. Descartes' dualism has a famous problem: if the mind takes up no space and has no physical properties, how can it push on the pineal gland? Nobody, Descartes included, could say. A non-physical mind also cannot be observed or measured, so a scientist cannot test claims about it.
Dualism still left a lasting gift. By treating the body as a machine, Descartes opened it to mechanical, scientific explanation; his account of reflexes, an automatic response with no mind involved, is the ancestor of the spinal reflexes you will meet later in this topic and in Unit 3.
The materialist approach makes predictions that can be checked: if the mind is what the brain does, then damaging, stimulating or drugging part of the brain should change the mind in a predictable way. That is exactly what the evidence in the rest of this topic shows, from Broca's patients to brain scans. Modern psychology therefore works from a materialist position, though philosophers still debate how a brain produces conscious experience.
Worked example
Discuss the mind-versus-body problem
Discuss the mind-versus-body problem, with reference to the materialist approach of Claudius Galen and the dualistic approach of René Descartes. (5 marks)
Step 1: State the problem
The mind-versus-body problem asks how the mind (thoughts, feelings, consciousness) is related to the physical body, in particular the brain.
A discussion starts by saying what is being discussed. Most marking guides give a mark for the problem itself.
Step 2: Describe the materialist approach with Galen
The materialist approach holds that the mind is produced by the physical body. Galen located mental functions in the brain, using evidence from head injuries in gladiators, dissection that traced nerves to the brain, and experiments such as cutting nerves that stopped a pig squealing. He explained temperament by the balance of the four humours, a physical cause.
Step 3: Describe the dualistic approach with Descartes
The dualistic approach holds that mind and body are separate kinds of thing. Descartes argued the mind is non-physical (it thinks and takes up no space) while the body is a physical machine, and that the two interact through the pineal gland.
Step 4: Compare and judge
Dualism cannot explain how something non-physical could move the body, and a non-physical mind cannot be measured, so its claims cannot be tested. The materialist approach predicts that changing the brain changes the mind, which evidence from brain damage, stimulation and imaging supports. Modern psychology therefore works from a materialist position.
"Discuss" asks for more than two descriptions: a point of comparison or a reasoned judgement earns the last marks.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The problem asks how mind and brain are related. Galen (materialist): the mind is a product of the physical brain, shown by injuries, dissection and experiments, with temperament from the humours. Descartes (dualist): a non-physical mind and a mechanical body interact in the pineal gland. Dualism cannot be tested and cannot explain the interaction; the materialist approach is testable and supported by evidence, so psychology works from it.
Method
State the problem in one sentence.
Give each approach, its figure and one piece of its reasoning or evidence.
Finish with a comparison or judgement, with a reason.
Watch out for
Calling Galen a dualist because he lived long ago. His explanations were physical.
Describing both approaches but never comparing them, which loses the marks for discussion.
Classify each statement as part of the materialist approach or the dualistic approach.
Psychology as a science. Settling questions with evidence instead of argument is what makes psychology a science. Psychologists use the scientific method: they turn a question into a testable prediction, collect data in a planned way, analyse it, and let the results decide. Other researchers then check the work through peer review and by repeating it.
The scientific method as psychologists use it. A conclusion often raises the next question.
Which of these claims could a psychologist test with an investigation?
Note
Other debates in Unit 1
Two more old debates run through the course: free will versus determinism (do we choose our behaviour, or is it caused?) and nature versus nurture (how much do genes and environment each shape us?). You meet them as lenses on later topics rather than as dot points here.
Exam tip
Discuss means both sides
"Discuss the mind-versus-body problem" wants the problem stated, both approaches each with its figure and reasoning (Galen: materialist, mental life in the brain and humours; Descartes: dualist, mind and body interacting through the pineal gland), and a comparison or judgement, such as which approach can be tested with evidence.
Summary
The mind-versus-body problem asks how the mind (thoughts, feelings, consciousness) is related to the body and brain.
Galen's materialist approach: mental life has physical causes; he located the mind in the brain from injuries, dissection and experiments, and linked temperament to humours.
Descartes' dualistic approach: a non-physical mind and a physical, machine-like body interact through the pineal gland.
Dualism cannot explain how a non-physical mind moves the body or be tested; the materialist approach predicts that changing the brain changes the mind, which evidence supports.
Psychology is the scientific study of mind and behaviour: questions become testable hypotheses, data decide, and peer review checks the work.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.