Lesson 9 of 10 · 18 min
Predicting the effects of localised brain damage
Use localisation of function to predict the cognitive and behavioural effects of damage to an area of the brain, including the aphasias, and to work out where damage is from a person's symptoms.
What you will be able to do
- Predict the cognitive and behavioural effects of damage to a named area, including which side of the body is affected.
- Distinguish Broca's aphasia, Wernicke's aphasia and the effects of damage to the arcuate fasciculus and Geschwind's territory.
- Work out the likely location of damage from a description of a person's difficulties.
- Explain the limits of predictions from localisation.
If a function is localised in one area, damage to that area should disrupt that function and leave others largely intact. That logic is how localisation was discovered (Broca worked backwards from his patients' speech to their brains), and it is how doctors and psychologists work today: knowing where a stroke or injury is lets them predict what a person will find difficult and plan their rehabilitation.
Damage can come from a stroke (a blood vessel in the brain blocked or burst), a traumatic brain injury (a blow or penetrating wound), a tumour, an infection, or surgery.
Predicting the effects of damage
Name the area and its lobe
For example, the left primary motor cortex, in the frontal lobe.
State its normal function
It starts voluntary movements of the opposite side of the body.
Predict the change
Weakness or paralysis, here of the right side of the body.
Check the side and what is spared
Motor and sensory effects are on the opposite side. Functions served by other areas, such as understanding speech, should be largely unaffected.
| Damaged area | Normal function | Likely effects of damage |
|---|---|---|
| Prefrontal cortex | Planning, decisions, regulating emotion and behaviour | Poor planning and judgement, impulsive or socially inappropriate behaviour, changes in personality |
| Primary motor cortex | Starts voluntary movement of the opposite side | Weakness or paralysis on the opposite side of the body |
| Primary somatosensory cortex | Touch, temperature, pain and position of the opposite side | Numbness or loss of feeling on the opposite side; poor sense of where a limb is |
| Primary visual cortex (occipital lobe) | Receiving visual information | Loss of part of the field of vision (damage on one side: the opposite half of what each eye sees) |
| Primary auditory cortex (temporal lobe) | Receiving sound | Difficulty hearing or recognising sounds |
| Broca's area | Producing speech | Broca's aphasia: slow, effortful speech; comprehension largely intact |
| Wernicke's area | Understanding language | Wernicke's aphasia: fluent but meaningless speech; poor comprehension |
| Cerebellum | Coordinating movement, balance and posture | Clumsy, uncoordinated movement; unsteady walking; poor balance |
| Medulla | Heart rate, breathing, blood pressure | Life-threatening loss of breathing or circulation control |
Pick a region and predict what damage there would change before you look. Then switch to "locate" and work backwards from a described change.
The aphasias. Damage to the language areas produces different aphasias (losses of language), and the differences are good evidence that each area has its own role.
- Broca's aphasia (damage to Broca's area): speech is slow, halting and effortful, with short phrases of mainly nouns and verbs and the small grammatical words left out ("Walk... dog... park"). Comprehension of everyday speech is relatively good, and the person usually knows their speech is wrong, which is frustrating. Writing is affected in a similar way.
- Wernicke's aphasia (damage to Wernicke's area): speech flows at a normal rate with normal rhythm and grammar, but it makes little sense, with wrong or made-up words ("I went to the flindering with my rester"). Comprehension is poor, and the person is often unaware that their speech does not make sense.
- Damage to the arcuate fasciculus: the person understands and speaks fluently but has great difficulty repeating what they hear, because the link from Wernicke's area to Broca's area is cut (conduction aphasia).
- Damage to Geschwind's territory: difficulty reading, writing and naming objects, because the link between a word's appearance, sound and meaning is disrupted.
Broca's aphasia
- Damage: left frontal lobe
- Speech: slow, effortful, telegraphic
- Comprehension: largely intact
- Aware of errors: usually
Wernicke's aphasia
- Damage: left temporal lobe
- Speech: fluent but meaningless
- Comprehension: poor
- Aware of errors: often not
After a stroke, a woman speaks quickly and with normal rhythm, but her sentences make no sense and she does not follow simple instructions. She seems unaware of the problem. Where is the damage most likely to be?
Worked example
Predict the effects of a stroke
A 64-year-old man has a stroke that damages part of his left frontal lobe, including Broca's area and the neighbouring part of the primary motor cortex. Predict two effects on his behaviour, and one ability you would expect to be largely unaffected. Justify each prediction. (4 marks)
Step 1: Effect of damage to Broca's area
Broca's area produces speech, so he is likely to have Broca's aphasia: slow, effortful, halting speech with the small grammatical words missing.
Step 2: Effect of damage to the primary motor cortex
The left primary motor cortex controls voluntary movement of the right side of the body, so he is likely to have weakness or paralysis of the right side, especially the face and arm (the part of the strip beside Broca's area).
Damage to the motor cortex affects the opposite side of the body (contralateral control).
Step 3: What should be spared
Understanding speech depends mainly on Wernicke's area in the temporal lobe, which was not damaged, so his comprehension of everyday speech should be largely intact.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Slow, effortful speech (Broca's aphasia), because Broca's area plans speech; weakness of the right side of the body, because the left motor cortex controls the right side; comprehension largely intact, because Wernicke's area in the temporal lobe is undamaged.
Method
For each damaged area: its normal function, then the change.
For motor and sensory areas, flip the side.
Name an ability served elsewhere as spared.
Watch out for
Predicting weakness on the left side.
Predicting that he will not understand speech. That is Wernicke's aphasia.
History
Phineas Gage (1848)
Phineas Gage was a railway construction foreman in Vermont, USA. In September 1848 an explosion drove a metre-long iron rod up through his left cheek and out of the top of his head. He survived, and could walk, talk and remember. But his doctor, John Harlow, reported that he had become impatient, rude and unable to stick to his plans, so changed that his friends said he was "no longer Gage". In 1994 Hanna Damasio and colleagues used Gage's skull and computer modelling to show that the rod had most likely damaged the prefrontal cortex, in their reconstruction on both sides (later reconstructions suggest the damage may have been mainly on the left).
Gage's case is famous evidence that the prefrontal cortex regulates personality and behaviour. It is also a warning about case studies: Harlow's reports were brief, later retellings exaggerated the change, and Gage later held a job driving stagecoaches in Chile, which suggests he recovered some of what he lost.
Worked example
Locate damage from a set of symptoms
A 45-year-old woman is struck on the back of the head in a cycling accident. A week later her doctor notes:
- She cannot see objects to her left, with either eye, although her eyes themselves are undamaged.
- She walks unsteadily, overshoots when reaching for a cup, and her speech is slightly slurred, though her words and grammar are normal.
- Her memory, understanding of speech and personality are unchanged.
(a) Identify the two areas most likely damaged, with the division or lobe of each. (b) Justify your answer with the evidence. (c) Explain why you could not be certain from these observations alone, and suggest how the damage could be confirmed.
Step 1: Locate the visual loss
Loss of the left half of what both eyes see, with healthy eyes, points to the visual cortex: the right primary visual cortex, in the right occipital lobe. Each hemisphere processes the opposite half of the visual field.
Damage to one eye would affect only that eye. A loss in both eyes on the same side must be in the brain, behind the point where the pathways from the two eyes meet.
Step 2: Locate the coordination problem
Unsteady walking, overshooting and slurred speech with normal language are problems of coordinating movement: the cerebellum, in the hindbrain. Both are at the back of the head, where she was struck.
Step 3: Use what is spared
Normal words and grammar rule out Broca's and Wernicke's areas; unchanged memory and personality suggest the temporal and frontal lobes were spared.
Step 4: (c) Limits and confirmation
Symptoms are indirect evidence: damage is rarely confined to one area, swelling in the first weeks can cause effects that later fade, and people's brains differ. An MRI scan would show the structure of the damaged areas directly.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Right primary visual cortex (occipital lobe) and cerebellum (hindbrain). (b) Loss of the left visual field in both eyes means the right visual cortex; unsteadiness, overshooting and slurred speech with normal language mean the cerebellum; both lie at the back of the head, where she was hit, and language, memory and personality areas are spared. (c) Damage may be widespread or temporary and brains differ; an MRI scan would show the damage.
Method
List each symptom and the function it disrupts.
Map each function to its area; flip sides for vision, movement and sensation.
Use spared abilities to rule areas out.
Check the locations fit the injury, then state the limits and how to confirm.
Watch out for
Naming the left visual cortex for loss of the left visual field.
Naming Broca's area because speech is slurred. Slurring with normal words and grammar is a coordination problem, not aphasia.
A tumour presses on the left primary somatosensory cortex. Which change is most likely?
The limits of prediction. Predictions from localisation are a starting point, not a certainty.
- Real damage is rarely neat: a stroke or injury usually affects several areas and the connections between them. (An MRI scan of Leborgne's preserved brain in 2007 showed damage that reached well beyond Broca's area.)
- Many functions, such as memory and attention, rely on networks across several areas, so damage to one area may only weaken them.
- People differ: the exact location of areas varies a little, and in some people (more often left-handed people) language is in the right hemisphere.
- The brain can partly reorganise after damage (neural plasticity, Topic 2), especially in children, so effects can lessen with time and rehabilitation.
Note
Care with real cases
Aphasia affects many Australians: the Stroke Foundation reports that about a third of people who have a stroke have aphasia. People with aphasia have the same intelligence and knowledge as before; it is their access to language that is damaged. Write about them as you would want to be written about: "a person with aphasia".
Summary
Damage to a localised area disrupts the function it serves and spares others, so knowing localisation predicts the effects of a stroke, injury or tumour.
Predict by naming the area and its function, then the change, and the side of the body for motor and sensory areas (the opposite side).
Broca's aphasia: slow, effortful speech with comprehension largely intact. Wernicke's aphasia: fluent, meaningless speech with poor comprehension. Arcuate fasciculus damage: poor repetition. Geschwind's territory damage: reading, writing and naming difficulties.
Prefrontal damage, as in Phineas Gage, changes planning, judgement and personality.
Predictions are limited: damage is rarely confined to one area, functions are often distributed, people differ, and the brain can partly reorganise.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.