Lesson 2 of 10 · 17 min
Early brain research: Gall, Flourens and Penfield
Describe Gall's phrenology, Flourens' ablation experiments and Penfield's electrical stimulation of the cortex, what each showed, its flaws, and the risks to the animals and people involved.
What you will be able to do
- Describe Gall's phrenology and explain why it is not scientific, and the idea it got right.
- Describe Flourens' ablation experiments and what they showed about the cerebrum, cerebellum and medulla.
- Describe Penfield's electrical stimulation during surgery and what his maps of the cortex showed.
- Consider the risks and costs to animals and people of early, invasive brain research.
Once the mind was placed in the brain, the next question was where in the brain each ability lives. In the 1800s and early 1900s there was no way to look inside a living head. Researchers could feel the skull, damage the brain of an animal and watch what changed, or open a patient's skull during surgery. Each method gave real knowledge, and each came at a cost.
History
Franz Gall and phrenology (around 1800)
Franz Gall (1758 to 1828) was a German physician. His ideas, which his colleague Johann Spurzheim popularised as phrenology, rested on four claims:
- The brain is the organ of the mind.
- The mind is made of separate faculties (Gall listed 27, such as language, memory for places, "benevolence" and "the instinct to steal"), each with its own area of the cortex.
- The more a faculty is used, the larger its area grows.
- The skull takes the shape of the brain beneath, so the bumps on a person's skull reveal their faculties.
Gall's evidence was the skulls of people with striking traits: he felt the heads of poets, pickpockets and people in asylums and found bumps to match.
Why phrenology failed. Its faculties were invented, not measured; the skull's outer shape does not follow the brain's surface; and Gall's evidence was anecdotes chosen because they fitted, while people who did not fit were explained away. Nothing could prove it wrong, so it was not science. It became a fashionable way to "read" character, and was used to justify prejudice.
What it got right. The idea that different areas of the cortex do different jobs, localisation of function, turned out to be correct. Gall had the right question and the wrong method.
History
Pierre Flourens and ablation (1820s)
Pierre Flourens (1794 to 1867) was a French physiologist who set out to test phrenology by experiment. He used ablation: removing or destroying a part of the brain of a living animal, mostly pigeons, and watching which behaviours changed as it recovered.
- Removing the cerebral hemispheres left a pigeon that could stand and fly if thrown, but sat still, did not eat unless fed, and did not respond to what it saw: the cerebrum was needed for perception, judgement and will.
- Removing the cerebellum left a pigeon that could see and wanted to move, but staggered and could not fly smoothly: the cerebellum coordinates movement.
- Damage to the medulla stopped breathing and killed the animal: it controls vital functions.
When he removed more and more of the cerebral hemispheres, every ability faded together rather than one at a time. Flourens concluded that the cortex works as a whole and that phrenology's faculties did not exist there.
Flourens was right about the cerebellum and the medulla, and his controlled experiments were a great advance on Gall's anecdotes. But his conclusion about the cortex was wrong for humans: within forty years, Broca's patients showed that one small area of the human cortex is needed for speech. His lesions were crude, a pigeon's cortex is far simpler than a human's, and his method harmed and killed many animals.
History
Wilder Penfield and electrical stimulation (1930s to 1950s)
Wilder Penfield (1891 to 1976) was a neurosurgeon who founded the Montreal Neurological Institute (1934). He operated on people with severe epilepsy to remove the brain tissue that started their seizures. To avoid damaging important areas, he developed the Montreal procedure:
- The patient was given a local anaesthetic and stayed awake. The brain itself has no pain receptors.
- Part of the skull was removed to expose the cortex.
- Penfield touched points on the cortex with an electrode carrying a weak current, and the patient said what they felt or the team watched what moved.
- Each point was marked with a numbered tag and recorded, building a map of the cortex.
Stimulating the strip in front of the central sulcus made muscles move; the strip behind it produced tingling or touch. Each side of the brain served the opposite side of the body.
What Penfield found. Stimulating the strip in front of the central sulcus (the primary motor cortex) made muscles on the opposite side of the body twitch or move. The strip just behind it (the primary somatosensory cortex) produced tingling or a feeling of touch, also on the opposite side. Each body part had its own patch, in order along the strip, and the patches for the lips, tongue and hands were far larger than those for the back or legs: the size of an area reflects how finely that part is controlled or felt, not how big it is. Drawn as a figure, the map is the distorted little person called the homunculus.
Stimulating the primary auditory cortex in the temporal lobe gave only a crude sound: usually a tone, a buzzing or a knocking. But in a small number of patients, stimulating other parts of the temporal lobe brought back a vivid experience, such as hearing music or a voice: 40 of the 520 patients whose temporal lobes were stimulated (7.7%; Penfield & Perot, 1963). Penfield took these as memories being replayed; later researchers have doubted that they were accurate memories.
Switch between phrenology, ablation and stimulation. For each, ask what it could show and what it could not.
A researcher removes part of a rabbit's brain and records how its movement changes over the following weeks. Which early technique is this?
Worked example
Describe and evaluate Penfield's technique
(a) Describe the technique Wilder Penfield used to investigate the cortex. (b) Explain what it showed about the primary motor cortex. (c) Give one limitation of using his patients to draw conclusions about the human brain.
Step 1: (a) Say what was done, to whom and why
During surgery for severe epilepsy, Penfield exposed the cortex of patients who were awake under a local anaesthetic. He applied a weak electric current to points on the cortex, recorded what each patient felt or what moved, and marked each point to build a map.
The patients could be awake because the brain has no pain receptors, and their reports were the data.
Step 2: (b) State the finding
Stimulating the primary motor cortex made muscles on the opposite side of the body move, with each body part represented in its own area in order along the strip; parts controlled finely, such as the hands and lips, had the largest areas.
Step 3: (c) Name a limitation
All his patients had epilepsy, so their brains may have been organised differently from people without it, which limits how far the maps generalise.
Any limitation must be specific to the method. Others: stimulation is not normal brain activity, and the reports of memories were subjective and rare.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Electrical stimulation of the exposed cortex of awake patients during epilepsy surgery, recording their responses as a map. (b) The primary motor cortex controls movement of the opposite side of the body, with each body part in its own area. (c) The patients all had epilepsy, so their brains may not be typical.
Method
Describe: who, what was done, what was recorded.
Link the finding to a specific area.
Give a limitation that comes from the method or the participants.
Watch out for
Saying the patients were under a general anaesthetic. They were awake so they could report.
Saying Penfield removed brain tissue to find out what it did. That was Flourens' method; Penfield removed tissue only to treat the epilepsy.
Knowledge at a cost. Much of what was learnt about the brain before the 1970s came from methods that harmed the animals or people involved. Flourens' pigeons were mutilated and many died. Penfield's patients underwent open brain surgery with the risks of infection, bleeding and seizures, though it was done to treat them and they agreed to it. Much of the rest came from people whose brains had been damaged by injury, stroke or disease, studied case by case.
Today, research with people must be approved by a human research ethics committee and follow principles such as informed consent, the right to withdraw and protection from harm. Animal research must be approved by an animal ethics committee and replace, reduce and refine the use of animals where it can. Above all, neuroimaging (the next lesson) lets researchers study the living, healthy brain without surgery.
Put these figures in the order in which they did their work, earliest first.
Common mistake
Flourens disproved phrenology, but not localisation
Flourens showed that the cerebellum and medulla have their own functions, which is localisation. What he denied was localisation within the cerebral cortex, and on that he was wrong for humans. Say which part of his conclusion held up.
Summary
Gall's phrenology claimed that 27 faculties each had an area of cortex readable from skull bumps; its method was anecdote, but its idea of localised function was right.
Flourens used ablation on animals (mostly pigeons): the cerebrum for perception and will, the cerebellum for coordinating movement, the medulla for vital functions; he wrongly concluded the cortex works as a whole.
Penfield stimulated the exposed cortex of awake patients during epilepsy surgery and mapped the motor and somatosensory strips, which serve the opposite side of the body.
Early knowledge of the brain came from risky, invasive practices on animals and patients; ethics committees and neuroimaging now limit that harm.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.