Lesson 2: Early brain research: Gall, Flourens and Penfield
Describe and evaluate Penfield's technique
SkillEarly brain research
Worked example
(a) Describe the technique Wilder Penfield used to investigate the cortex. (b) Explain what it showed about the primary motor cortex. (c) Give one limitation of using his patients to draw conclusions about the human brain.
Step 1: (a) Say what was done, to whom and why
During surgery for severe epilepsy, Penfield exposed the cortex of patients who were awake under a local anaesthetic. He applied a weak electric current to points on the cortex, recorded what each patient felt or what moved, and marked each point to build a map.
The patients could be awake because the brain has no pain receptors, and their reports were the data.
Step 2: (b) State the finding
Stimulating the primary motor cortex made muscles on the opposite side of the body move, with each body part represented in its own area in order along the strip; parts controlled finely, such as the hands and lips, had the largest areas.
Step 3: (c) Name a limitation
All his patients had epilepsy, so their brains may have been organised differently from people without it, which limits how far the maps generalise.
Any limitation must be specific to the method. Others: stimulation is not normal brain activity, and the reports of memories were subjective and rare.
Answer
(a) Electrical stimulation of the exposed cortex of awake patients during epilepsy surgery, recording their responses as a map. (b) The primary motor cortex controls movement of the opposite side of the body, with each body part in its own area. (c) The patients all had epilepsy, so their brains may not be typical.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe: who, what was done, what was recorded.
Link the finding to a specific area.
Give a limitation that comes from the method or the participants.
Watch out for
Saying the patients were under a general anaesthetic. They were awake so they could report.
Saying Penfield removed brain tissue to find out what it did. That was Flourens' method; Penfield removed tissue only to treat the epilepsy.