Lesson 1: Mind versus body, and psychology as a science
Discuss the mind-versus-body problem
SkillThe mind-versus-body problem
Worked example
Discuss the mind-versus-body problem, with reference to the materialist approach of Claudius Galen and the dualistic approach of René Descartes. (5 marks)
Step 1: State the problem
The mind-versus-body problem asks how the mind (thoughts, feelings, consciousness) is related to the physical body, in particular the brain.
A discussion starts by saying what is being discussed. Most marking guides give a mark for the problem itself.
Step 2: Describe the materialist approach with Galen
The materialist approach holds that the mind is produced by the physical body. Galen located mental functions in the brain, using evidence from head injuries in gladiators, dissection that traced nerves to the brain, and experiments such as cutting nerves that stopped a pig squealing. He explained temperament by the balance of the four humours, a physical cause.
Step 3: Describe the dualistic approach with Descartes
The dualistic approach holds that mind and body are separate kinds of thing. Descartes argued the mind is non-physical (it thinks and takes up no space) while the body is a physical machine, and that the two interact through the pineal gland.
Step 4: Compare and judge
Dualism cannot explain how something non-physical could move the body, and a non-physical mind cannot be measured, so its claims cannot be tested. The materialist approach predicts that changing the brain changes the mind, which evidence from brain damage, stimulation and imaging supports. Modern psychology therefore works from a materialist position.
"Discuss" asks for more than two descriptions: a point of comparison or a reasoned judgement earns the last marks.
Answer
The problem asks how mind and brain are related. Galen (materialist): the mind is a product of the physical brain, shown by injuries, dissection and experiments, with temperament from the humours. Descartes (dualist): a non-physical mind and a mechanical body interact in the pineal gland. Dualism cannot be tested and cannot explain the interaction; the materialist approach is testable and supported by evidence, so psychology works from it.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State the problem in one sentence.
Give each approach, its figure and one piece of its reasoning or evidence.
Finish with a comparison or judgement, with a reason.
Watch out for
Calling Galen a dualist because he lived long ago. His explanations were physical.
Describing both approaches but never comparing them, which loses the marks for discussion.