Lesson 3: Neuroimaging with PET, MRI, fMRI and EEG
Choose a neuroimaging technique for each question
SkillPET, MRI, fMRI and EEG
Worked example
For each research question, choose PET, MRI, fMRI or EEG, and justify your choice with a property of the technique.
(a) Is the hippocampus of people with long-term epilepsy smaller than that of people without it? (b) Which areas of the brain become more active when people look at photographs of their own family compared with strangers? Participants include 15-year-olds who will be scanned several times. (c) How many milliseconds after a word appears does the brain respond differently to real words and made-up words?
Step 1: (a) Decide whether structure or function is needed
The size of a structure is a question of structure. MRI shows structure in fine detail (about 1 mm) with no radiation, so the hippocampus can be measured accurately.
Step 2: (b) Function, where, and repeated scans of young people
The question asks where activity rises during a task: function with good spatial resolution. fMRI detects changes in blood oxygen to a few millimetres and uses no radiation, so it is safe to repeat with young participants. PET would also show activity but needs a radioactive injection each time.
Step 3: (c) A question about timing
The question is about when, to the millisecond. EEG records electrical activity as it happens, with millisecond temporal resolution; fMRI and PET are seconds to minutes too slow.
Answer
(a) MRI: shows structure in fine detail. (b) fMRI: shows where activity increases, to a few millimetres, without radiation, so it can be repeated. (c) EEG: records activity to the millisecond.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Decide whether the question needs structure or function.
For function, decide whether it asks where (spatial) or when (temporal).
Check for risks: radiation (PET), metal or a narrow scanner (MRI and fMRI).
Justify with the property, not with "it is best".
Watch out for
Choosing fMRI for (a). It would work, but a size question needs only structure, which MRI gives.
Choosing PET for (b) without mentioning that it needs a radioactive tracer, which matters for repeated scans of teenagers.