Lesson 8 of 9 · 16 min

Symmetry and conservation

Describe how matter–antimatter symmetry and the symmetry of particle interaction diagrams keep charge, baryon number and lepton number conserved.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe matter–antimatter symmetry and explain why particles are created and destroyed in particle–antiparticle pairs.
  • Describe how rotating a vertex or moving a particle across a reaction (as its antiparticle) gives another allowed interaction.
  • Explain how these symmetries keep charge, baryon number and lepton number conserved.

Turn the electron–electron scattering diagram on its side and look again. Now an electron and a positron come in, meet, become a photon, and the photon turns back into an electron and a positron. That is a real process too. Particle interactions are full of symmetries like this, and each one keeps the conservation laws intact.

Key idea

Matter–antimatter symmetry

For every particle there is an antiparticle with the same mass and opposite charge, baryon number and lepton number. So a particle–antiparticle pair always has total Q=0Q = 0, B=0B = 0 and L=0L = 0.

That is why creating a particle–antiparticle pair (pair production) or removing one (annihilation) changes none of the conserved totals. Particles can also be created or destroyed in other reactions, such as beta decay, provided the complete reaction conserves these totals.

A gamma-ray photon of 2 MeV2\unit{MeV} passes near a nucleus. Why can it produce an electron and a positron, but not two electrons?

Choose one answer

One vertex, three processes. Rotating the same electron–photon vertex gives (a) emission of a photon, (b) annihilation and (c) pair production. Charge and lepton number balance in all three. These are vertices within larger diagrams: an isolated real photon cannot create a pair or be the sole product of annihilation, because energy and momentum must also balance.

Key idea

Crossing symmetry

If a reaction is allowed, you can move any particle to the other side of the arrow, as long as you replace it with its antiparticle. The new reaction also conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number (though it still needs enough energy to happen).

It works because an antiparticle has the opposite quantum numbers. Removing +1+1 from one side and adding −1-1 to the other side changes both totals by the same amount, so the balance is kept.

Four weak interactions linked by crossing symmetry. Each conserves QQ, BB and LeL_e.
ReactionNameHow it is obtained
n→p+e−+νˉen \to p + e^- + \bar{\nu}_ebeta-minus decaystarting reaction
p+e−→n+νep + e^- \to n + \nu_eelectron capturereverse it, then move νˉe\bar{\nu}_e to the right as νe\nu_e
p→n+e++νep \to n + e^+ + \nu_ebeta-plus decay (in a nucleus)from electron capture, move e−e^- to the right as e+e^+
νˉe+p→n+e+\bar{\nu}_e + p \to n + e^+inverse beta decayfrom beta-plus decay, move νe\nu_e to the left as νˉe\bar{\nu}_e
Interactive

Compare crossed diagrams

Electron capture is neutron decay with two lines crossed. Switch between beta-minus, beta-plus and electron capture and watch which lines change side and which arrows flip.

Worked example

Predict a reaction with crossing symmetry

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology free

Beta-minus decay of a neutron, n→p+e−+νˉen \to p + e^- + \bar{\nu}_e, is observed. A proton-rich nucleus can instead capture one of its own inner electrons.

(a) Use symmetry to write the electron-capture reaction for a proton.

(b) Verify that it conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number.

(c) Explain why the symmetry guarantees this.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Reverse or cross particles from a known allowed reaction.

  2. Replace each crossed particle by its antiparticle.

  3. Verify QQ, BB and LL explicitly.

Watch out for

  • Moving a particle across without changing it to its antiparticle.

Start from n→p+e−+νˉen \to p + e^- + \bar{\nu}_e and move the electron to the left-hand side. Which reaction do you get?

Choose one answer

Key idea

Swapping matter for antimatter

Replace every particle in an allowed reaction with its antiparticle and you get another reaction that conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number. For example, n→p+e−+νˉen \to p + e^- + \bar{\nu}_e becomes nˉ→pˉ+e++νe\bar{n} \to \bar{p} + e^+ + \nu_e, the decay of an antineutron. Every total flips sign on both sides, so if they matched before, they still match. (The weak force treats the spins of particles and antiparticles slightly differently, but the antiparticle reaction still happens.)

The pion decays by π+→μ++νμ\pi^+ \to \mu^+ + \nu_\mu. Using matter–antimatter symmetry, how does the π−\pi^- decay?

Choose one answer
Extension: every conservation law comes from a symmetry

In 1918 the mathematician Emmy Noether proved that every continuous symmetry of the laws of physics gives a conserved quantity. If the laws are the same today as tomorrow, energy is conserved. If they are the same here as over there, momentum is conserved. Conservation of charge comes from a deeper symmetry in how the electromagnetic field is described (a gauge symmetry, which is where 'gauge bosons' get their name).

History

Chien-Shiung Wu: a symmetry that breaks

Physicists assumed nature could not tell left from right (parity symmetry). In 1956 Tsung-Dao Lee and Chen-Ning Yang pointed out that no one had tested this for the weak force. Chien-Shiung Wu led the experiment: she cooled cobalt-60 nuclei to a few thousandths of a kelvin and lined up their spins in a magnetic field. The beta-decay electrons came out mostly in one direction, opposite the nuclear spin, so the weak force does distinguish left from right. Lee and Yang received the 1957 Nobel Prize; Wu, whose experiment proved it, was not included. Symmetries are tested by experiment, not assumed.

Exam tip

Explaining symmetry and conservation

A strong answer to 'describe how symmetry maintains conservation' has three parts: (1) the symmetry (each particle has an antiparticle with opposite quantum numbers; diagrams can be rotated or particles crossed); (2) an example reaction or vertex; (3) the reason totals stay equal (pairs have zero total QQ, BB, LL, or crossing changes both sides by the same amount).

Summary

  • Every particle has an antiparticle with opposite charge, baryon number and lepton number, so a particle–antiparticle pair has zero total of each.

  • Pair production and annihilation create or destroy particles in pairs, keeping QQ, BB and LL unchanged.

  • A vertex can be rotated, and a particle moved across a reaction as its antiparticle, to give another allowed interaction (crossing symmetry).

  • Replacing every particle in a reaction with its antiparticle gives another reaction that conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number.

  • Wu's experiment showed that the weak force breaks left–right (parity) symmetry; symmetries must be tested by experiment.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 8 of 90% read

Save your progress with a free account