Lesson 9 of 9 · 18 min
Evidence, accelerators and the Big Bang
Examine the evidence for the Standard Model, from cosmic-ray tracks to the Higgs boson, the accelerators and collaborations that found it, and how it supports the Big Bang theory.
What you will be able to do
- Outline how particle physics models developed alongside particle accelerators, and the contributions of Wu, Feynman and Higgs.
- Explain why discovering heavier particles needs higher-energy accelerators.
- Describe accelerators such as the Large Hadron Collider and the Australian Synchrotron as multinational collaborations, including Australia's part in finding the Higgs boson.
- Interpret experimental evidence for particles, including particle tracks and a mass peak.
- Describe evidence from the Standard Model that supports the Big Bang theory.
Every particle in the Standard Model chart was first a prediction or a surprise, and then a measurement. Some were found in cosmic rays falling on mountain tops; most were made in accelerators of ever-increasing energy. How do physicists know a particle exists when it lasts less than a trillionth of a second?
| Year | Discovery | How |
|---|---|---|
| 1932 | positron (predicted by Dirac, 1928–31) | cosmic-ray tracks in a cloud chamber (Anderson) |
| 1936 | muon | cosmic rays (Anderson and Neddermeyer) |
| 1947 | pion and the first strange particles (kaons) | cosmic rays, in photographic emulsions and cloud chambers |
| 1956 | electron antineutrino | nuclear reactor experiment (Cowan and Reines) |
| 1964 | quark model (Gell-Mann, Zweig); found as predicted | Brookhaven accelerator, bubble chamber |
| 1968 | point-like charges inside the proton (quarks) | electrons scattered off protons at the Stanford Linear Accelerator |
| 1974–1977 | charm quark, tau lepton, bottom quark | electron–positron and proton collisions (SLAC, Brookhaven, Fermilab) |
| 1979 | gluon | three-jet events in electron–positron collisions (DESY, Hamburg) |
| 1983 | W and Z bosons | proton–antiproton collider at CERN |
| 1995 | top quark | Tevatron proton–antiproton collider (Fermilab) |
| 2000 | tau neutrino | Fermilab (DONUT experiment) |
| 2012 | Higgs boson | Large Hadron Collider, CERN (ATLAS and CMS) |
Key idea
Why bigger accelerators?
To create a particle of mass , a collision must supply at least its rest energy . The top quark () and the Higgs boson () needed collisions of hundreds of GeV and more. Higher energy also means shorter de Broglie wavelength (), so faster particles can resolve smaller structures, like the quarks inside a proton.
Why did the discovery of the W and Z bosons (1983) have to wait for a collider that could reach collision energies of hundreds of GeV?
A particle that lives for never reaches a detector. Physicists find it from what it decays into. For each event they add up the energies and momenta of the decay products to find the mass of the particle that made them. Random background events give a smooth curve; a real particle adds a peak at its mass.
Illustration (not real data) of how the Higgs boson appeared in 2012: events with two photons, plotted against the mass the photon pair would have come from. The bump at sits on top of a smooth background.
In the graph, what is the best evidence that a new particle exists?
History
Wu, Feynman and Higgs
- Chien-Shiung Wu (1912–1997) made the most precise early tests of beta decay and in 1956–57 showed that the weak force violates parity (mirror) symmetry, a result that reshaped the theory of the weak interaction.
- Richard Feynman (1918–1988) developed quantum electrodynamics, the quantum theory of the electromagnetic force, and invented the diagrams used throughout this topic. He shared the 1965 Nobel Prize with Julian Schwinger and Sin-Itiro Tomonaga.
- Peter Higgs (1929–2024) proposed in 1964, as did François Englert and Robert Brout and others, a field that gives particles mass, and predicted its boson. Higgs and Englert shared the 2013 Nobel Prize, the year after the boson was found.
Key idea
Science as a shared project
The Large Hadron Collider at CERN, near Geneva, is a ring that collides protons at up to . It was built and is run by CERN's member states, with thousands of scientists from more than 100 countries working on its experiments. Its two largest experiments, ATLAS and CMS, each involve several thousand scientists, engineers and students.
The Australian Synchrotron in Clayton, Melbourne, opened in 2007. It accelerates electrons to to make intense X-rays and infrared light for research in medicine, materials, biology and environmental science. It was funded by the Victorian and Australian governments with universities, research organisations and New Zealand partners, and is now run by ANSTO.
No single nation could afford, build or staff these machines alone. They are shared between governments, universities and research organisations.
History
Australians and the Higgs boson
Physicists from Australian universities, including the University of Melbourne, the University of Sydney and the University of Adelaide, were members of the ATLAS collaboration that announced the Higgs boson on 4 July 2012. They helped build and test parts of the detector, ran data processing on an Australian computing centre linked to the worldwide LHC grid, and analysed the data. The ARC Centre of Excellence for Particle Physics at the Terascale (CoEPP), set up in 2011, brought Australian experimental and theoretical physicists together for this work.
Worked example
How the antineutrino was first detected
In 1956 Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines placed tanks of water near a nuclear reactor, which emits huge numbers of electron antineutrinos. They looked for the reaction .
(a) Show that this reaction conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number.
(b) The positron quickly annihilates with an electron, producing two gamma photons. Calculate the energy of each photon in MeV, assuming both particles are at rest. ()
(c) A few microseconds later, the neutron is captured by a nucleus, which emits another gamma ray. Explain why detecting this sequence of gamma rays was convincing evidence for antineutrinos.
Step 1: Conservation
: and . : and . : and . All conserved.
Step 2: Photon energy
Each photon carries one particle's rest energy:
Momentum is zero before, so two equal photons go in opposite directions and share the total energy equally.
Step 3: Why the sequence is convincing
A pair of photons is the fingerprint of a positron, and a delayed gamma ray is the fingerprint of a neutron. Background radiation rarely produces both, in that order, a few microseconds apart. The signal also dropped when the reactor was switched off, linking it to the reactor's antineutrinos.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) : ; : ; : . (b) About each. (c) The delayed coincidence of positron annihilation photons followed by a neutron-capture gamma ray is the unique signature of the reaction, and it depended on the reactor being on.
Method
Check conservation with a line for each law.
Annihilation at rest: each photon has .
Evidence: identify the signature, rule out background, look for dependence on the source.
Key idea
The Standard Model and the Big Bang
Particle physics lets us test what the very early Universe was like:
- Quark–gluon plasma. Colliding heavy nuclei at the LHC and at Brookhaven briefly melts protons and neutrons into free quarks and gluons, the state the whole Universe was in for its first few microseconds.
- Three neutrino families. Measurements of how the Z boson decays show there are exactly three light neutrino types. Big Bang theory needs that number to correctly predict how much helium formed in the first few minutes (about 25 % of ordinary matter by mass), and the predictions match.
- Unified forces at high energy. At the energies of the W and Z masses the weak and electromagnetic forces behave as one electroweak force, as they would have in the first trillionth of a second.
- Pair production and annihilation. In the hot early Universe, photons constantly made particle–antiparticle pairs, which annihilated again. As it cooled, a tiny excess of matter (about one particle in a billion) was left over, which is everything we see; the photons from that era are still here, cooled into the cosmic microwave background.
Which observation from particle physics gives the most direct evidence about the state of the Universe in its first few microseconds?
Exam tip
Evidence questions
When asked to 'examine evidence', say what was observed, how it was measured and what it shows, and judge how strong it is (Was it repeated? Was a prediction confirmed? Could background explain it?). A confirmed prediction, like the or the Higgs boson, is especially strong evidence.
Summary
The Standard Model grew from cosmic-ray discoveries (positron, muon, pion) to accelerator discoveries (quarks, gluon, W and Z, top quark, Higgs boson).
Higher energies are needed to create heavier particles () and to probe smaller distances.
Short-lived particles are identified from their decay products, as a peak at their mass above a smooth background.
Wu showed the weak force breaks parity symmetry; Feynman built quantum electrodynamics and its diagrams; Higgs predicted the field and boson that give particles mass.
Large accelerators such as the LHC and the Australian Synchrotron are multinational collaborations, and Australian physicists in ATLAS helped discover the Higgs boson.
Quark–gluon plasma, three neutrino families, electroweak unification and matter–antimatter annihilation link the Standard Model to the Big Bang.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.