Lesson 6 of 9 · 18 min
Conservation laws in particle reactions
Test a particle reaction for conservation of charge, baryon number and lepton number, decide whether it can happen, and identify an unknown particle.
What you will be able to do
- Apply conservation of charge, baryon number and lepton number (each family separately) to a particle reaction.
- Decide whether a reaction is possible and state which law a forbidden reaction breaks.
- Use the conservation laws to identify an unknown particle in a reaction.
A chemical equation must balance atoms on both sides. A particle reaction must balance too, but the things that balance are charge, baryon number and lepton number. If any one of them changes, the reaction never happens, no matter how much energy is available.
Key idea
The conservation laws
In every particle reaction, the totals before equal the totals after for:
- electric charge ,
- baryon number ,
- lepton number for each family: , and separately.
Energy (including rest-mass energy) and momentum must be conserved as well.
Testing a reaction
List every particle on each side
Include any neutrinos, antineutrinos and photons.
Make a table of Q, B and the lepton numbers
One row per particle, one column per quantity. Antiparticles get the opposite signs.
Total each column on each side
Compare the totals before and after.
Conclude
If every total matches, the reaction is allowed by these laws. If any differs, it is forbidden: name the law it breaks.
The lab starts with neutron decay. Delete the antineutrino and see which law fails. Then type your own reaction, such as .
Worked example
Is this pion decay possible?
Determine whether the decay conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number.
Step 1: Charge
Before: . After: . Conserved.
Step 2: Baryon number
The pion is a meson () and the products are leptons (). . Conserved.
Step 3: Muon lepton number
Before: . After: the antimuon is an antilepton () and the muon neutrino a lepton (): . Conserved.
Step 4: Electron and tau lepton numbers
No electron- or tau-family particles appear, so on both sides.
Step 5: Conclude
All conservation laws are satisfied, and the pion () is heavier than the muon (), so the decay is possible. It is in fact the main way a decays.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Charge (), baryon number () and () are all conserved, so the decay is possible.
Method
Check charge, then baryon number, then each lepton family.
Show the totals before and after.
Which conservation law does the reaction violate?
Worked example
Why a muon never decays to an electron and a photon
Muons decay by , but the simpler decay has never been observed. Use conservation laws to explain why.
Step 1: Check the observed decay
Charge: . : . : . All conserved.
Step 2: Check the proposed decay, charge and baryon number
Charge: . Baryon number: . Both conserved.
Step 3: Check total lepton number
: . The total lepton number is conserved too.
This is why it is tempting to say the decay is allowed.
Step 4: Check each lepton family
: , and : . Both family numbers change.
Step 5: Conclude
The decay breaks conservation of muon lepton number and electron lepton number, so it does not occur. The neutrinos in the real decay carry away the muon's family number.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
conserves charge, baryon number and total lepton number, but not () or (), so it is forbidden.
Method
Check charge and baryon number.
Check each lepton family number separately, not just the total.
Watch out for
Stopping at the total lepton number and concluding the decay is allowed.
Common mistake
Check each family, not just the total
has total lepton number on the right, matching the left. But goes from 0 to and from 0 to , so it is forbidden. The real decay is .
Worked example
Identify the unknown particle
A muon neutrino strikes a neutron in a detector: . Use conservation laws to identify particle .
Step 1: Total each quantity before
; ; ; .
Step 2: Subtract what the proton carries
The proton has , , .
Step 3: Find X's quantum numbers
; ; ; .
Step 4: Match a particle
A particle with charge , no baryon number and muon lepton number is the muon, .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
is a muon, .
Method
Total each quantity on the complete side.
Subtract the known particles on the other side.
Match the remaining , and to a particle.
Watch out for
Choosing an electron: it has the right charge but and .
In the beta-minus decay of a neutron, . Identify particle .
Note
Allowed by the numbers, but still impossible?
Passing the , and tests is necessary but not enough. A free particle can only decay into products whose total rest mass is less than its own. A free proton () can't decay to a neutron (), so decay () happens only inside a nucleus, where the nucleus supplies the energy. And conserves , and but not momentum, so annihilation at rest gives at least two photons.
Exam tip
Show the totals
'Determine whether this reaction is possible' earns marks for working: a table (or a line for each law) with the total before and after, then a clear verdict that names any law broken. Charge first, then baryon number, then each lepton family.
Summary
Charge, baryon number and each lepton family number (, , ) are conserved in every particle reaction.
To test a reaction, total , and each on both sides; if any total changes, the reaction is forbidden.
To find an unknown particle, work out the , and it needs to balance each side, then match a particle.
Energy and momentum must also be conserved, so a free particle can only decay into lighter products, and annihilation at rest gives at least two photons.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.