Lesson 3 of 10 · 18 min
Alpha, beta and gamma radiation
Compare the charge, mass, ionising ability and penetrating ability of alpha, beta-minus, beta-plus and gamma radiation, and use them to identify radiation and choose radioisotopes.
What you will be able to do
- Describe alpha, beta-minus, beta-plus and gamma radiation: what each is, its charge and its mass.
- Explain why strongly ionising radiation is weakly penetrating, and the reverse.
- Identify the radiation from a source using absorber data.
- Choose a suitable radioisotope for medical imaging or treatment and justify the choice.
When Henri Becquerel found in 1896 that uranium salts fogged photographic plates in the dark, nobody knew what the "rays" were. Within a few years, Rutherford had sorted them by how far they could get through matter: one kind stopped by a sheet of paper, one that got through paper but not a few millimetres of aluminium, and one that went through almost anything. He named them alpha, beta and gamma, and the names stuck.
Add paper, aluminium and lead between the source and the detector. Which radiation does each one stop? Can you stop gamma completely?
| Property | Alpha, | Beta-minus, | Beta-plus, | Gamma, |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Helium-4 nucleus (2 p, 2 n) | Electron | Positron (anti-electron) | High-energy photon (electromagnetic wave) |
| Symbol | or | or | or | |
| Charge | 0 | |||
| Mass | kg (about 4 u) | kg | kg | 0 |
| Ionising ability | Strong | Moderate | Moderate (then annihilates) | Weak |
| Penetrating ability | Low: stopped by paper, skin or a few cm of air | Medium: stopped by a few mm of aluminium | Annihilates with an electron almost at once, giving two gamma rays | High: reduced, never fully stopped, by several cm of lead or metres of concrete |
Key idea
Ionising versus penetrating
Radiation loses energy each time it knocks an electron out of an atom (ionises it). So the more strongly it ionises, the faster it runs out of energy, and the less far it penetrates.
- Alpha particles are massive, slow and doubly charged, so they interact with almost every atom they pass, creating thousands of ions per millimetre. They lose their energy within a few centimetres of air.
- Beta particles have a single charge and tiny mass and move much faster, so they ionise less and travel further.
- Gamma rays have no charge, so they interact only occasionally. They ionise weakly and penetrate deeply.
A radiation passes through a sheet of paper but is stopped by 3 mm of aluminium. It is most likely:
Note
Dose depends on where the source is
Outside the body, alpha is the least hazardous: it can't get through the dead outer layer of skin. Inside the body (breathed in or swallowed), it is the most hazardous, because all its energy is dumped in a tiny volume of living tissue. Radon gas, an alpha emitter that seeps from granite, is a major cause of lung cancer for this reason. Gamma is the main hazard from a source outside the body.
Worked example
Identify radiation from absorber data
A student measures the count rate from a radioactive source with different absorbers between the source and a GM tube. The background count rate is 25 counts per minute.
- No absorber: 480 counts per minute
- Sheet of paper: 478 counts per minute
- 3 mm of aluminium: 160 counts per minute
- 2 cm of lead: 60 counts per minute
Determine which types of radiation the source emits. Justify your answer.
Step 1: Correct for background
Subtract 25 from each reading: no absorber 455, paper 453, aluminium 135, lead 35 counts per minute.
Background radiation reaches the detector whatever absorber is used, so it must be removed before comparing.
Step 2: Test for alpha
Paper reduces the corrected count rate from 455 to 453, a difference within random variation. So there is no alpha radiation.
Step 3: Test for beta
3 mm of aluminium reduces it from 453 to 135. Radiation that passes through paper but is stopped by a few mm of aluminium is beta.
Step 4: Test for gamma
Radiation still gets through the aluminium (135), and 2 cm of lead reduces but does not stop it (35). That is gamma.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The source emits beta and gamma radiation but no alpha. (Cobalt-60 behaves like this.)
Method
Subtract background from every reading.
Paper stops alpha; a few mm of aluminium stops beta; lead reduces gamma.
Look for a significant drop at each absorber.
Watch out for
Not subtracting background, then claiming lead stops gamma when only background is left.
Treating a drop of 2 counts per minute as evidence of alpha. Random decay makes small differences meaningless.
Knowing these properties lets doctors pick the right radioisotope for the job.
- Imaging needs radiation that escapes the body to reach a detector and does as little damage as possible on the way: a gamma emitter. Technetium-99m emits only gamma, has a half-life of 6 h (long enough for a scan, short enough to be gone in a day or two), and can be attached to chemicals that collect in bones, the heart or the brain.
- PET scans use a beta-plus emitter such as fluorine-18 in a glucose-like molecule. Each positron annihilates with a nearby electron, giving two gamma rays that fly off in opposite directions, so detectors on either side locate the tumour.
- Treatment needs the energy deposited in the tumour. Iodine-131, a beta emitter, collects in the thyroid and destroys thyroid cancer cells within a few millimetres. External gamma beams from cobalt-60 can be aimed at a tumour from several directions.
A hospital wants a radioisotope to inject into a patient for imaging their kidneys with a gamma camera outside the body. Which isotope is most suitable?
Common mistake
"Gamma is stopped by lead"
Lead reduces the intensity of gamma radiation, roughly halving it for each centimetre or so, but never stops all of it. In an absorber experiment, a count rate that drops but doesn't fall to background behind lead tells you gamma is present.
Summary
Alpha: helium nucleus, charge , about 4 u; strongly ionising, stopped by paper or a few cm of air.
Beta-minus: electron, charge ; beta-plus: positron, charge . Both moderately ionising; beta-minus is stopped by a few mm of aluminium; a positron annihilates almost at once.
Gamma: photon, no charge, no mass; weakly ionising, only reduced by thick lead or concrete.
The more strongly radiation ionises, the faster it loses energy and the less it penetrates.
Identify radiation by which absorbers reduce the corrected count rate.
Imaging uses gamma emitters with short half-lives; treatment uses radiation that deposits its energy in the target tissue.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.