Lesson 6: Budget outcomes, causes and fiscal stance
From a forecast surplus to an $85 billion deficit, 2019–20
SkillsCyclical and structural causesBudget outcomes and stance
Worked example
In December 2019, Treasury's Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook (MYEFO) forecast an underlying cash surplus of $5.0 billion for 2019–20. The Final Budget Outcome was a deficit of $85.3 billion (4.3% of GDP): receipts were $33.1 billion lower and payments $57.7 billion higher than the MYEFO estimates (Treasury, Final Budget Outcome 2019–20). Calculate the turnaround and explain its cyclical and structural causes.
Step 1: The turnaround
: the outcome was $90.3 billion worse than forecast. Lower receipts () and higher payments () make ; the small difference is net Future Fund earnings, which the measure left out in 2019–20, and rounding.
Step 2: Lower receipts, mostly cyclical
From March 2020 the pandemic restrictions cut incomes, profits and spending. Income, company and GST receipts fell with them: the automatic stabilisers at work.
Step 3: Higher payments, mostly structural
The government decided on large temporary support from March 2020, including the JobKeeper Payment and cash flow boosts for employers: discretionary spending. Some higher payments were cyclical too, as more people claimed income support.
Step 4: Stance and effect
The balance fell 4.3 percentage points of GDP: strongly expansionary. It supported household incomes and kept workers attached to employers, cushioning the fall in aggregate demand.
Answer
The outcome was $90.3 billion worse than forecast. Receipts fell mainly for cyclical reasons (the downturn), and payments rose mainly for structural reasons (discretionary pandemic support); the stance was strongly expansionary.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare the outcome with the forecast to find what changed.
Receipts that fall with the economy: cyclical. New programs and payments decided by the government: structural.
Watch out for
Calling the whole deficit a policy choice: more than a third of the turnaround was lost receipts.