Lesson 6: Budget outcomes, causes and fiscal stance
The stance of the 2022–23 budget outcome
SkillsBudget outcomes and stanceCyclical and structural causes
Worked example
The underlying cash balance was −$32.0 billion (−1.4% of GDP) in 2021–22 and $22.1 billion (0.9% of GDP) in 2022–23 (Treasury, Final Budget Outcome). Calculate the change in the balance in dollars and in percentage points of GDP, state the stance, and give one cyclical cause.
Step 1: Change in dollars
: the balance improved by $54.1 billion.
Step 2: Change as a share of GDP
percentage points of GDP.
Step 3: Stance
The balance rose, so the stance was contractionary: the budget took more out of the economy than the year before, restraining aggregate demand.
Step 4: A cyclical cause
Treasury's outcome report attributes the higher tax receipts to elevated commodity prices and a strong labour market. Neither was a policy decision: both are cyclical.
Answer
The balance rose by $54.1 billion, or 2.3 percentage points of GDP: a contractionary stance. A cyclical cause: high commodity prices (and a strong labour market) lifted tax receipts.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Change = new balance − old balance, keeping deficits negative.
A rise in the balance is contractionary; a fall is expansionary.
Watch out for
Subtracting 32.0 from 22.1 and getting −9.9: a deficit is negative, so subtracting it adds.