Lesson 7: Recent federal budgets, 2018–19 to 2025–26
The 2020–21 budget outcome: stance, causes and effects
SkillsBudget outcomes and stanceCyclical and structural causes
Worked example
In 2020–21 the underlying cash deficit was $134.2 billion (6.4% of GDP), after 4.3% of GDP in 2019–20. Payments in 2020–21 included $68.2 billion for the JobKeeper Payment, $20.9 billion for cash flow boosts to employers and $14.8 billion for the Coronavirus supplement (Treasury, Final Budget Outcome 2020–21). Analyse the stance, its causes and its effects.
Step 1: Stance
The balance fell a further percentage points of GDP: expansionary, on top of an already expansionary 2019–20.
Step 2: Structural causes
The three measures named total billion dollars of discretionary support, about three-quarters of the deficit. They were temporary: JobKeeper ended in March 2021.
Step 3: Cyclical causes
Receipts were held down by the weak economy (real GDP 3.2% lower over the year to the September quarter 2020), and payments to people on income support were higher with unemployment near 7%.
Step 4: Effects
The stance supported aggregate demand and incomes through the trough, and the recovery was faster than forecast: the deficit was $79.5 billion smaller than the 2020–21 Budget had estimated. The cost was higher public debt (net debt rose to $592.2 billion at June 2021) and the interest on it in later years: an intertemporal trade-off.
Answer
A strongly expansionary stance (balance down 2.1 points of GDP), caused mainly by temporary discretionary support ($103.9 billion in three measures) with cyclical weakness in receipts; it supported demand through the trough at the cost of higher debt.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Stance from the change in the balance (% of GDP).
Structural causes: name the decisions and their size; cyclical causes: the economy's effect on receipts and payments.
Effects: on AD and the objectives now, and on debt later.
Watch out for
Treating the deficit as permanent: most of the measures were designed to end, which is why the deficit fell so fast in 2021–22.