Lesson 5: Accuracy, reliability and efficacy of indicators
How much did the unemployment rate hide in April 2020?
SkillsJudging indicatorsCalculating economic rates
Worked example
In March 2020 the labour force was 13 635.3 thousand with 709.4 thousand unemployed (5.2%). In April 2020 the labour force was 13 178.3 thousand with 831.2 thousand unemployed (6.3%) (ABS via RBA table H5). (a) By how much did the labour force fall? (b) If everyone who left the labour force had instead been counted as unemployed, what would the April unemployment rate have been, to one decimal place? (c) What does this show about the unemployment rate as an indicator?
Step 1: Fall in the labour force
thousand people left the labour force.
Step 2: Add them back as unemployed
Unemployed thousand, in a labour force of thousand.
Step 3: The alternative rate
Step 4: Evaluate
The published rate (6.3%) rose 1.1 points; on this wider measure it would have risen 4.2 points. Many who lost work could not search while businesses were closed, so they counted as "not in the labour force": hidden unemployment. The rate was accurate to its definition, but its efficacy as a measure of spare labour was poor in April 2020.
(a) 457.0 thousand. (b) About . (c) The unemployment rate understated the fall in labour use, because people who stopped searching were not counted; its efficacy was low in this scenario.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Hidden unemployment: people who want work but are outside the labour force.
Test the headline rate against a wider measure from the same period.
Watch out for
Adding the leavers to the unemployed but not to the labour force.
Saying the ABS figure was "wrong": it measured its definition accurately.