Lesson 10: Suasion, permits, provision and regulation, and evaluating them
How trading permits cuts the cost of a cap
SkillEvaluating interventions
Worked example
Two illustrative firms each emit 50 tonnes of a pollutant a year. Firm A can cut emissions at $20 a tonne; firm B at $50 a tonne (each cost is the same for every tonne, up to 50 tonnes). The government caps total emissions at 60 tonnes and gives each firm 30 permits (one permit allows one tonne).
(a) Calculate the total cost of meeting the cap if permits cannot be traded. (b) Permits can be traded at $35 each. Explain what the firms do and calculate the total cost of abatement. (c) Show that both firms are better off.
Step 1: Without trading
Each firm must cut tonnes. A: . B: . Total $1400.
Step 2: What trading does
A can cut a tonne for $20 and sell the permit for $35, so it cuts all 40 tonnes the cap requires and sells its 20 spare permits to B. B pays $35 a permit instead of cutting at $50, so it buys 20 permits and cuts nothing. Emissions: A 10 + B 50 = 60 tonnes, still the cap.
Step 3: Total cost of abatement
Only A cuts: . Society saves .
The permit payments () are a transfer from B to A, not a cost to society.
Step 4: Each firm's position
A: $800 of abatement − $700 from selling permits = $100, down from $400. B: $700 for permits, down from $1000.
Answer
(a) $1400. (b) A cuts 40 tonnes and sells 20 permits to B; abatement costs $800. (c) A's net cost falls to $100 and B's to $700.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Without trade, each firm cuts its own share.
With trade, the cheapest abater cuts most and sells its spare permits.
Payments for permits are transfers; only abatement is a cost to society.
Watch out for
Counting the permit payments as a cost to society.