Lesson 10: Suasion, permits, provision and regulation, and evaluating them

Evaluate a carbon tax against a cap-and-trade scheme

SkillsEvaluating interventionsExternality diagrams

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar

Use the sources to evaluate whether a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade scheme is the better way to correct the market failure from greenhouse gas emissions in Australian electricity generation. Include a diagram. (12 marks)

Source 1. Australia's Climate Change Act 2022 legislates a target of cutting emissions to 43% below 2005 levels by 2030, and net zero by 2050.

Source 2. Australia's carbon pricing mechanism charged large emitters a fixed price of $23 per tonne of carbon dioxide-equivalent from 1 July 2012; it was repealed with effect from 1 July 2014.

Source 3. Under the Safeguard Mechanism, reformed from 1 July 2023, each large facility has an emissions baseline that falls by 4.9% a year to 2029–30. Facilities below their baseline earn Safeguard Mechanism Credits they can sell to facilities above theirs.

Source 4 (illustrative). The cost of cutting a tonne of emissions ranges from under $20 for some generators to over $100 for others.

1 of 6 steps
  1. Step 1: Explain the market failure (comprehending)

    Emissions are a negative production externality: MSC lies above MPC by the external cost of the emissions. Generators produce QmQ_m, where MPB = MPC, more than the optimum Q∗Q^*, and the welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MPB from Q∗Q^* to QmQ_m.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Explain the failure with a labelled diagram.

  2. Analyse each measure with evidence from the sources.

  3. Weigh both against stated criteria.

  4. Make and justify a judgement.

Watch out for

  • Describing both measures without comparing them or reaching a judgement.

  • Quoting a source without saying what it shows about the measure.

Save your progress with a free account