Lesson 10: Suasion, permits, provision and regulation, and evaluating them
Evaluate a carbon tax against a cap-and-trade scheme
SkillsEvaluating interventionsExternality diagrams
Worked example
Use the sources to evaluate whether a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade scheme is the better way to correct the market failure from greenhouse gas emissions in Australian electricity generation. Include a diagram. (12 marks)
Source 1. Australia's Climate Change Act 2022 legislates a target of cutting emissions to 43% below 2005 levels by 2030, and net zero by 2050.
Source 2. Australia's carbon pricing mechanism charged large emitters a fixed price of $23 per tonne of carbon dioxide-equivalent from 1 July 2012; it was repealed with effect from 1 July 2014.
Source 3. Under the Safeguard Mechanism, reformed from 1 July 2023, each large facility has an emissions baseline that falls by 4.9% a year to 2029–30. Facilities below their baseline earn Safeguard Mechanism Credits they can sell to facilities above theirs.
Source 4 (illustrative). The cost of cutting a tonne of emissions ranges from under $20 for some generators to over $100 for others.
Step 1: Explain the market failure (comprehending)
Emissions are a negative production externality: MSC lies above MPC by the external cost of the emissions. Generators produce , where MPB = MPC, more than the optimum , and the welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MPB from to .
Step 2: Draw and refer to the diagram
A labelled negative production externality: MPB = MSB, MPC, MSC above it, , , the welfare loss shaded. Show a tax equal to the external cost moving MPC up to MSC, and say a cap would fix at directly.
Step 3: Analyse the tax
A tax per tonne sets the price of emitting (Source 2: $23 a tonne), so generators cut where it costs less than the tax. It gives certainty of price and raises revenue that could fund rebates for low-income households. But the government cannot be sure how far emissions will fall, because it does not know abatement costs, and Source 2 shows such a tax can be politically fragile.
Step 4: Analyse cap and trade
A cap fixes the quantity, matching a legislated target (Source 1). Trading means the cheapest cuts are made first: with costs from under $20 to over $100 a tonne (Source 4), this greatly lowers the total cost. Source 3 shows Australia has used a declining-baseline version since 2023. The permit price is uncertain, which makes investment planning harder, and monitoring each facility is costly.
Step 5: Weigh against criteria
Effectiveness: the cap guarantees the target; the tax does not. Efficiency: both use prices, so both find cheap cuts; trading is essential when costs vary widely. Equity: both raise electricity prices, a regressive burden unless revenue is returned. Innovation: both reward cheaper abatement. Unintended consequences: both risk "carbon leakage" if production moves overseas.
Step 6: Judge
Because the government's goal is a fixed quantity by a fixed date (Source 1) and abatement costs differ widely (Source 4), a cap-and-trade scheme is the better choice, ideally with a price floor and ceiling to limit price swings and some revenue used to offset the burden on low-income households.
Answer
A cap-and-trade scheme is better suited to a legislated quantity target and to wide differences in abatement cost, while a tax gives price certainty and revenue. Recommend cap-and-trade with protections for low-income households.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Explain the failure with a labelled diagram.
Analyse each measure with evidence from the sources.
Weigh both against stated criteria.
Make and justify a judgement.
Watch out for
Describing both measures without comparing them or reaching a judgement.
Quoting a source without saying what it shows about the measure.