Lesson 8: The tragedy of the commons and property rights
Why each boat overfishes a shared stock
SkillThe commons and property rights
Worked example
Five boats share an open-access fishery. If one boat catches an extra 10 tonnes this season, it earns an extra $30 000. Because the stock is then smaller, next season's total catch for the fishery falls by an amount worth $60 000, shared equally among the five boats.
(a) Calculate the net gain to the boat that fishes more. (b) Calculate the net effect on the fishery as a whole. (c) Explain why this leads to the tragedy of the commons.
Step 1: The boat's own cost
The boat bears one-fifth of the future loss: .
Step 2: The boat's net gain
. Fishing more pays.
Step 3: The net effect on everyone
. The fishery as a whole is worse off.
Step 4: Why it repeats
Every boat faces the same incentive, so all fish more. The $48 000 of the future loss that each boat does not bear is an external cost imposed on the others. With no owner able to exclude anyone, the stock is run down.
Answer
(a) +$18 000. (b) −$30 000. (c) Each boat keeps all of its gain but bears only a fifth of the cost, so every boat overfishes and the stock declines.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Private cost = the user's share of the shared cost.
Compare private benefit with private cost, then with total cost.
Watch out for
Using the whole $60 000 as the boat's cost: the point is that it bears only a share.