Lesson 8: The tragedy of the commons and property rights

Why each boat overfishes a shared stock

SkillThe commons and property rights

Worked example

  • Complex familiar

Five boats share an open-access fishery. If one boat catches an extra 10 tonnes this season, it earns an extra $30 000. Because the stock is then smaller, next season's total catch for the fishery falls by an amount worth $60 000, shared equally among the five boats.

(a) Calculate the net gain to the boat that fishes more. (b) Calculate the net effect on the fishery as a whole. (c) Explain why this leads to the tragedy of the commons.

1 of 4 steps
  1. Step 1: The boat's own cost

    The boat bears one-fifth of the future loss: $60 000÷5=$12 000\$60\,000 \div 5 = \$12\,000.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Private cost = the user's share of the shared cost.

  2. Compare private benefit with private cost, then with total cost.

Watch out for

  • Using the whole $60 000 as the boat's cost: the point is that it bears only a share.

Save your progress with a free account