Lesson 7 of 11 · 16 min
Two changes at once
Combine a shift of demand with a shift of supply, say which of price or quantity is certain and which depends on the sizes of the shifts, and explain why house and Valentine's Day flower prices rise despite more supply.
What you will be able to do
- Show two shifts on one diagram and find the new equilibrium.
- State which of equilibrium price and quantity is certain, and which is indeterminate, for each of the four combinations.
- Explain how house prices can rise despite more supply, and why Valentine's Day roses cost more although far more are sold.
In February florists across Australia order many times their usual stock of red roses. Supply has increased sharply. If you had learnt only one shift at a time, you would predict the price of roses to fall. Yet roses cost more in Valentine's week than at any other time of year. The answer is that something else changed too.
Two shifts, one at a time. When two non-price factors change together, treat them in turn. Shift the first curve and note what happens to price and quantity. Shift the second and note the same. Where both shifts push a variable the same way, its direction is certain. Where they push it opposite ways, its direction is indeterminate: it depends on which shift is larger.
| Demand | Supply | Equilibrium price | Equilibrium quantity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Increases (right) | Increases (right) | Indeterminate | Rises |
| Decreases (left) | Decreases (left) | Indeterminate | Falls |
| Increases (right) | Decreases (left) | Rises | Indeterminate |
| Decreases (left) | Increases (right) | Falls | Indeterminate |
Key idea
Same direction moves quantity; opposite directions move price
When both curves shift the same way, quantity is certain (both shifts push it the same way) and price depends on which shift is larger. When they shift opposite ways, price is certain and quantity depends on the sizes.
Pick a demand factor and a supply factor, then change the size of each shift. Watch which of price and quantity can change direction as the sizes change, and which never does.
Valentine's Day roses. Two things change in the week before 14 February.
- Demand for red roses increases enormously: tastes and custom make roses the gift of the day. D shifts far to the right.
- Supply to the florists increases too: growers and importers bring forward harvests and fly in extra stems. S shifts right, but stems cost more to grow, chill and freight in a rush, so it shifts by less.
Both shifts raise the quantity sold. The demand shift pushes the price up and the supply shift pushes it down, but the demand shift is larger, so the price rises.
Valentine's Day roses: demand shifts right by more than supply, so the price rises from to even though far more roses are supplied and sold.
Suppose, one February, demand for roses rose by less than supply. What would happen to the price and quantity of roses compared with the rest of the year?
House prices despite more supply. The syllabus's other puzzle is housing. In 2021 builders were busier than they had been for years, helped by the federal HomeBuilder grant, yet national home values rose 22.1% over the year, one of the largest annual rises on record (CoreLogic, January 2022). Demand grew by much more than supply:
- The Reserve Bank cut the cash rate to a record low of 0.10% in November 2020, so mortgage interest rates fell and buyers could borrow more.
- Households had built up savings during the 2020 lockdowns and many wanted more space to work from home.
- Investors expected prices to keep rising.
New housing adds only a small share to the stock of dwellings each year, and it takes a long time to approve land and build. Supply shifts right slowly while demand can shift a long way quickly, so prices rose.
Demand for housing (low interest rates, population growth, expectations) shifts by more than supply (new building). Change the sizes: how much faster would supply have to grow for prices to fall?
Worked example
House prices rising despite more supply
In a growing Australian city, the number of new dwellings completed each year rises to a record, yet the median house price rises by 15% over the year. Over the same year the population grows strongly through migration and mortgage interest rates fall.
(a) Identify the shifts of demand and supply.
(b) Explain how the price can rise despite the increase in supply, with reference to a diagram.
(c) What can you conclude about the change in the quantity of housing?
Demand for housing shifts right by more than supply, so the price rises despite record building.
Step 1: Supply
Record completions add to the homes available at every price: supply shifts right.
Step 2: Demand
Population growth adds buyers and lower interest rates let them borrow more: demand shifts right.
Step 3: Price
The supply shift pushes the price down; the demand shift pushes it up. The price rose, so the demand shift must have been larger than the supply shift.
When both curves shift the same way, price is indeterminate in theory. The data settle it: the observed rise tells you which shift dominated.
Step 4: Why supply grows slowly
New dwellings each year are a small addition to the existing stock, and approvals and construction take years, so supply is inelastic in the short run and shifts slowly, while demand can shift quickly.
Step 5: Quantity
Both shifts raise quantity, so the quantity of housing traded and occupied rises, whatever the relative sizes.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Demand shifts right (population growth, lower interest rates); supply shifts right (record completions). (b) The demand shift is larger than the supply shift, so the new equilibrium price is higher. (c) The quantity of housing rises.
Method
Identify each shift separately.
Say which variable both shifts push the same way (certain).
Use the data, or the relative sizes, to decide the other.
Watch out for
Concluding that more supply "should" lower the price and that the market is not working.
Drawing equal shifts, which shows no change in price.
Quick check
4 marks
In the market for Australian beef, a drought forced graziers to sell off breeding cattle, so herds are smaller in the following years, while a new trade deal raises demand from overseas buyers. Show the effect of both changes on the market for beef in those following years.
Show both changes on the diagram.
What happens to the equilibrium price and quantity of beef?
Common mistake
Don't let the diagram decide for you
When you draw two shifts, your diagram will always show some answer for the indeterminate variable, depending on how far you happened to move each curve. Say in words that it is indeterminate and what it depends on, unless the question tells you which shift is larger.
Exam tip
Answering a two-shift question
State each change, the curve it acts on and the direction. Say which variable is certain and why ("both shifts raise quantity"). Then say the other depends on the relative size of the shifts, and use any evidence in the stimulus (a price that actually rose) to say which shift must have been larger.
Summary
With two shifts, take them one at a time and combine the effects.
Both curves shifting the same way: quantity certain, price indeterminate.
Curves shifting opposite ways: price certain, quantity indeterminate.
Valentine's roses and 2021 house prices: demand grew by more than supply, so prices rose despite more supply.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.