Lesson 11 of 11 · 20 min

Investigating an Australian market

Select data on a real Australian market, explain its price trends with shifts of demand and supply, evaluate the effects on consumers and businesses, and write it up as an extended response.

What you will be able to do

  • Select reliable data and information on the price and quantity in a specific market.
  • Explain a trend in prices as shifts of demand and supply, with diagrams.
  • Evaluate the effects of market forces on consumers and businesses.
  • Structure an extended response that uses data, diagrams and a judgement.

The syllabus asks you to study this topic "through the lens of the economic problem in a specific current Australian context and market". That means taking the model off the page and into a market where prices really moved, finding the data, and explaining why. This lesson walks through five Australian markets as cases, then sets out how to investigate one of your own.

Investigating a market

  1. Define the market

    Name the good, the buyers and the sellers, and where they trade (fine Merino wool sold at auction to overseas mills; established houses in Brisbane).

  2. Find the price over time

    Use a reliable, dated source: ABARES for crops, AWEX and Australian Wool Innovation for wool, Meat & Livestock Australia for cattle, the Department of Industry's Resources and Energy Quarterly for minerals, CoreLogic (now Cotality) and the ABS for housing, the ABS and Fair Work Commission for wages.

  3. Find the events

    List what changed for buyers and for sellers in the same period: weather, costs, incomes, interest rates, trade decisions, population.

  4. Match events to shifts

    Decide which curve each event shifts and which way. Check against the quantity data: a price rise with a quantity fall points to a fall in supply; a price rise with a quantity rise points to a rise in demand.

  5. Draw the diagram

    One diagram per period, labelled with the market's own axes and dates.

  6. Evaluate

    Who gained and who lost: consumers, producers, workers, governments? In the short run and the long run?

Case 1: wool. Australia is the world's largest producer and exporter of fine Merino wool, most of it sold to processors in China. The Eastern Market Indicator, the benchmark wool price, reached a record of about 2,116 cents a kilogram (clean) in August 2018 and had fallen to about 1,110 cents by the end of June 2020.

In 2018 drought across eastern Australia cut the wool clip as growers reduced their flocks: supply shifted left, and the price rose. From 2019, trade tensions between the United States and China, and then in 2020 the closure of clothing shops around the world during COVID-19, cut the demand for wool garments and so for raw wool: demand shifted left, and the price fell steeply.

In 2020, clothing shops around the world closed during COVID-19 lockdowns. Show the effect on the market for Australian wool.

Demand (D)
Supply (S)

Nothing has shifted yet.

Case 2: beef cattle. After the 2019 drought, rain returned in 2020 and graziers set out to rebuild their herds. They held breeding cattle back from sale (supply of cattle to market shifted left) and bid against each other for young cattle to restock (demand rose). The Eastern Young Cattle Indicator reached an all-time record of 1,191 cents a kilogram (carcase weight) on 24 January 2022. Once herds were rebuilt, many more cattle came to market, and by July 2023 the indicator had fallen below 700 cents for the first time since March 2020.

Case 3: iron ore. Iron ore is one of Australia's largest exports, sold mostly to China's steel mills. As China's steel output surged in 2021, the price of Australian iron ore fines averaged US$197 a tonne in June 2021 (free on board, monthly average; the daily benchmark for ore delivered to China briefly passed US$230 in May). In the second half of 2021 China ordered its steel mills to cut output, demand for iron ore fell, and in November 2021 the price averaged US$78 a tonne.

Iron ore in the second half of 2021: China's cuts to steel output shifted demand left, and the price of Australian iron ore fell from an average of US$197 a tonne in June to US$78 in November.

Case 4: wheat. After three wet La Niña years, Australia harvested a record 40.5 million tonnes of wheat in 2022–23 (ABARES): a large increase in supply. Yet growers were paid high prices that year, because Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 cut grain exports from the Black Sea, reducing world supply. Australian wheat is sold into a world market, so the world price, not the size of the Australian crop alone, sets what growers receive.

Case 5: housing. In 2021 national home values rose 22.1% (CoreLogic) while the Reserve Bank's cash rate sat at a record low of 0.10%, as you saw in the lesson on two changes at once. From May 2022 the Reserve Bank raised the cash rate, mortgage repayments rose, and demand for housing fell: national values fell through most of 2022 before rising again in 2023 as population growth and a shortage of homes for rent pushed demand back up.

Interactive

Australian market scenarios

For each news event, decide which curve shifts and which way, or whether no curve shifts at all. The diagram then shows the new equilibrium.

Worked example

Explaining the fall in wool prices, 2018 to 2020

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology free

Stimulus: The Eastern Market Indicator (EMI), the benchmark price of Australian wool, reached a record of about 2,116 cents a kilogram (clean) in August 2018. Drought had cut the national wool clip. By the end of June 2020 the EMI was about 1,110 cents. Over 2019 the United States and China raised tariffs on each other's goods, and in 2020 clothing stores around the world closed during COVID-19 lockdowns. Most Australian wool is processed in China.

(a) Calculate the percentage change in the EMI from August 2018 to June 2020.

(b) Analyse the changes in the wool market over the period, using demand and supply.

(c) Evaluate the effect on Australian woolgrowers.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Calculate any change asked for from the original value.

  2. Split the period into phases and identify one shift for each.

  3. Use elasticity to explain the size of the price change.

  4. Evaluate with a judgement: who bore the change, short run and long run.

Watch out for

  • Dividing by the 2020 value, giving −90.6%.

  • Shifting supply right to explain the fall in price: the evidence (tariffs, shop closures) points to demand.

Evaluating the effects of market forces. Evaluating means making a judgement against a criterion and supporting it with evidence. Useful criteria for a market:

  • Consumers: the price paid, the quantity and choice available, and who can no longer afford the good (rising rents hit low-income renters hardest).
  • Businesses and producers: revenue and profit (a higher price with inelastic demand raises revenue), and the signal to invest or leave the industry (high cattle prices rewarded herd rebuilding).
  • Efficiency: whether the price mechanism moved resources to where buyers value them most, and how quickly.
  • Equity: whether the outcome is fair (rationing by price excludes those who cannot pay).
  • Short run and long run: a price spike is painful now but calls forth more supply later (high iron ore prices led to new mines).

Using Case 2 (beef cattle), evaluate the effect of the 2020–22 rise in cattle prices on two groups: graziers who were rebuilding their herds, and Australian households buying beef. Make a judgement about which group was affected more.

Write it out as you would in an exam. Put maths between dollar signs, like $x^2 + 1$. Worth 1 mark.

0 / 4000

Exam tip

Structuring an extended response

  1. Introduction: name the market and the trend, with dated figures from the stimulus.
  2. Analysis: for each period or event, name the curve that shifted and why, draw and refer to a labelled diagram, and link to the price and quantity data. Use elasticity where it explains the size of a change.
  3. Evaluation: judge the effects on consumers and businesses against a stated criterion, short run and long run, using evidence.
  4. Conclusion: answer the question directly.

Quote numbers with their dates and sources, and never write "currently" without a date.

Summary

  • Investigate a market by finding dated price and quantity data, listing the events, matching each to a shift, and drawing the diagrams.

  • Wool (2018–20), beef (2020–23), iron ore (2021), wheat (2022–23) and housing (2021–23) show demand and supply shifts in real Australian markets.

  • In a world market, world demand and supply set the price Australian producers receive.

  • Evaluate against criteria (consumers, producers, efficiency, equity, short and long run) with evidence, and make a judgement.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 11 of 110% read

Save your progress with a free account