Lesson 1 of 11 · 13 min
Markets, goods and consumer sovereignty
Explain what a market is and what consumer sovereignty means, and classify goods and services as private, public, merit, substitutes or complements.
What you will be able to do
- Explain what a market is, with examples that are not physical places.
- Explain consumer sovereignty and its limits.
- Describe private, public and merit goods, and substitutes and complements.
At a wool sale in Yennora in western Sydney, buyers for overseas mills bid on bales from hundreds of farms, and the auctioneer knocks each lot down to the highest bid. At the same moment, someone in Cairns pays for a coffee by tapping a phone, and a mining company in Perth agrees to ship iron ore to a steel mill in China. Each of these is a market.
Definition
Market
A market is any arrangement that brings buyers and sellers together to exchange a good, a service or a resource at a price.
A market need not be a place. The Australian Securities Exchange, online wool auctions, the rental listings in your suburb and the labour market for electricians are all markets.
In Topic 2 you met the two markets in the circular flow. Households buy goods and services from businesses in the goods and services market, and businesses hire land, labour, capital and enterprise from households in the resources (factor) market. This topic zooms in on one market at a time, to see how its price is set.
Every arrow in the circular flow passes through a market. Wages are the price in the labour market; the price of a coffee is set in the market for coffee.
Who decides what gets produced? In a market economy, no planner decides how many litres of milk or how many electric cars Australia should make. Businesses produce what buyers are willing to pay for. When buyers switch from one product to another, sales and profits rise for one and fall for the other, and resources follow the money.
Definition
Consumer sovereignty
Consumer sovereignty is the idea that consumers, through what they choose to buy, decide what goods and services are produced and in what quantities. Each dollar spent is a "vote" for that product.
Plant-based milks are a good example. As more Australians chose oat and almond milk, supermarkets gave them more shelf space and dairy companies started making their own. Nobody ordered the change: buyers' choices did.
Consumer sovereignty has limits, and you will use them when you evaluate markets:
- Advertising shapes what people want, so firms partly decide what consumers "choose".
- Market power: where one or two firms dominate, buyers have little to choose between.
- Income: each dollar is a vote, so people with more income have more say over what is produced.
- Information: buyers may not know enough to choose well (the safety of a used car, the quality of a financial product).
Which situation is the clearest example of consumer sovereignty?
Kinds of goods. Goods differ in two ways that matter for whether markets provide them. A good is excludable if people who don't pay can be kept from using it, and rival if one person's use leaves less for others.
| Kind | Characteristics | Australian examples | Does the market provide it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Private good | Excludable and rival | A meat pie, a haircut, a tonne of wheat | Yes: sellers can charge everyone who uses it |
| Public good | Non-excludable and non-rival | Street lighting, national defence, a tsunami warning system, flood levees | Not enough: people can use it without paying (free riders), so it is hard to sell |
| Merit good | Worth more to the person and society than people judge it to be (often with benefits to others too) | School education, vaccinations, preventive health checks | Too little: people under-value it, so governments provide or subsidise it |
Common mistake
Public is not the same as government-provided
"Public good" is a technical term. A public school place is rival (one more student means a bigger class) and excludable (enrolment can be limited), so it is not a public good: it is a merit good that governments provide. A lighthouse's beam is a true public good: every ship nearby uses it, and one ship's use takes nothing from another.
Goods are also related to each other through demand.
- Substitutes are used in place of each other: beef and lamb, Netflix and Stan, a train trip and a car trip. When the price of one rises, buyers switch to the other.
- Complements are used together: cars and petrol, printers and ink, coffee and milk. When the price of one rises, buyers want less of both.
These relationships matter in later lessons, because a change in the price of a related good shifts a good's demand curve.
Classify each good or pair.
Worked example
Classify goods and explain consumer sovereignty
A regional council in Queensland provides (i) flood warning sirens along the river, (ii) free flu vaccinations for residents over 65, and (iii) a council swimming pool that charges an entry fee.
(a) Classify each as a private, public or merit good, with a reason.
(b) In the same town, a new café selling plant-based meals closes within a year while the bakery next door opens a second shop. Explain how this shows consumer sovereignty.
Step 1: (i) Flood sirens
Everyone within earshot is warned whether or not they paid (non-excludable), and one person hearing the siren does not stop another hearing it (non-rival). A public good.
A public good needs both characteristics. Because no one can be made to pay for the warning, a private firm could not sell it, so the council provides it.
Step 2: (ii) Flu vaccinations
A vaccination is rival and excludable, but people tend to under-value it: it protects the person and also slows the spread to others. A merit good, which is why the council provides it free.
Step 3: (iii) The swimming pool
Entry can be refused to people who don't pay (excludable) and a crowded pool is less useful to each swimmer (rival). It is a private good, even though the council runs it. (You could argue for merit good, since swimming lessons and exercise have wider benefits, if you give that reason.)
Step 4: (b) Consumer sovereignty
Residents spent their money at the bakery rather than the café. Those "dollar votes" made the bakery profitable enough to expand and left the café without enough revenue to stay open. Buyers' choices, not a planner, decided which product the town's resources went to.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(i) Public good: non-excludable and non-rival. (ii) Merit good: under-valued by individuals, with benefits to others. (iii) Private good: excludable and rival. (b) Consumers' spending decided which business grew and which closed, so resources followed their choices.
Method
Test each good: excludable? rival? under-valued by individuals?
Classify and give the characteristic as the reason.
For consumer sovereignty, link buyers' spending to what producers make.
Watch out for
Calling anything the council provides a public good. Provision by government is not the test.
Describing consumer sovereignty as "the customer is always right" without linking spending to production.
Exam tip
Describing a good
When you describe a kind of good, give its defining characteristics and an example, and say what that means for the market: "A public good is non-excludable and non-rival, such as street lighting. Because people can benefit without paying, firms cannot sell it profitably, so the market under-provides it and governments supply it."
Summary
A market is any arrangement that brings buyers and sellers together to trade at a price; it need not be a place.
Consumer sovereignty: buyers' spending decides what is produced. It is limited by advertising, market power, unequal incomes and poor information.
Private goods are excludable and rival; public goods are neither, so markets under-provide them; merit goods are under-valued by individuals, so governments provide or subsidise them.
Substitutes are used instead of each other; complements are used together.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.