Lesson 11 of 13 · 16 min
Acid–base indicators
Explain how an indicator works as a weak acid with coloured conjugate forms, why it changes colour at over about , and choose one for a titration.
What you will be able to do
- Describe an indicator as a weak acid (or base) whose conjugate forms have different colours, and explain its colour change with Le Châtelier's principle.
- Explain why the colour change is centred on and spans about .
- Distinguish the end point of a titration from its equivalence point.
- Choose an indicator whose range falls within the steep part of a titration curve, at its equivalence point.
Red cabbage juice turns red in vinegar and green in soapy water. Phenolphthalein is colourless in acid and bright pink in base. Each of these colour changes is an equilibrium shifting, and once you see which equilibrium, you can predict the pH where the colour changes and choose the right indicator for any titration.
Key idea
An indicator is a weak acid with two colours
An acid–base indicator is a weak acid, , (or a weak base) whose conjugate forms have different colours:
- Add acid: rises and the equilibrium shifts left, so the colour shows.
- Add base: removes and the equilibrium shifts right, so the colour shows.
Only a few drops of a dilute indicator are used, so it does not noticeably change the pH of the solution it is in.
Why the colour changes at pH = pKa
For the indicator, , which rearranges to
When , that is when , the ratio is 1: equal amounts of both forms and an in-between colour. The eye sees one colour clearly once that form is roughly ten times more concentrated than the other. when , or ; it is at . So the colour change spans about .
Key idea
Where an indicator changes colour
An indicator changes colour at , over a range of about . The data book lists measured ranges, which are not always exactly two units wide (the eye is more sensitive to some colours). Use the data book's range when you have it.
Slide the pH from 4 to 10. Where are and equal, and over what range does the colour visibly change? Then switch to methyl orange and phenolphthalein.
Colour-change ranges from the data book, with each marked. Dashed lines: equivalence points of titrations of with (5.3), with (7.0) and ethanoic acid with (8.7).
Methyl red has and changes from pink (acidic) to yellow (basic). What colour is it in a solution of pH ?
Definition
End point and equivalence point
- The equivalence point is where the acid and base have been mixed in exactly the mole ratio of the balanced equation. It is a property of the reaction, whether or not you can see it.
- The end point is where the indicator changes colour, and where you stop adding titrant.
A good indicator makes the end point coincide with the equivalence point, to within a drop.
Key idea
Choosing an indicator
Near the equivalence point, one drop of titrant changes the pH by several units: the steep, vertical part of the titration curve. Choose an indicator whose colour-change range lies within that steep part, ideally with the equivalence-point pH inside its range.
| Titration | pH at equivalence | Suitable indicators |
|---|---|---|
| Strong acid–strong base | (steep from about 4 to 10) | Bromothymol blue, phenol red, phenolphthalein, methyl red |
| Weak acid–strong base | above 7 (about 8–9) | Phenolphthalein |
| Strong acid–weak base | below 7 (about 5–6) | Methyl red, bromocresol green |
The pH at equivalence is not always 7. A weak acid titrated with a strong base leaves the conjugate base of the weak acid, which makes the solution basic; a weak base titrated with a strong acid leaves a weakly acidic conjugate acid.
Worked example
Choose an indicator for titrating vinegar
Diluted vinegar (ethanoic acid) is titrated with sodium hydroxide. The titration curve shows a steep rise from about pH to pH , with the equivalence point at pH .
Using the data book, (a) choose a suitable indicator and (b) explain why methyl orange would be unsuitable.
Ethanoic acid titrated with , with the colour-change ranges of methyl orange (lower band) and phenolphthalein (upper band).
Step 1: Match the range to the equivalence pH
Phenolphthalein changes colour over pH –. That range contains the equivalence pH of and lies within the steep section, so it changes colour within a drop of equivalence. Phenolphthalein is suitable.
The end point (colour change) must coincide with the equivalence point.
Step 2: Check methyl orange
Methyl orange changes over pH –. On this curve, that pH is reached in the buffer region, after only a few millilitres of base, long before the equivalence point.
Step 3: Explain the consequence
With methyl orange, the end point would come far too early. The titre would be much too small, and the calculated acid concentration far too low.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Phenolphthalein, whose range (–) contains the equivalence pH and lies on the steep section. (b) Methyl orange changes at pH –, in the buffer region, so the end point would come long before equivalence and the titre would be too small.
Method
Find the equivalence pH and the steep section of the curve.
Pick the indicator whose range lies within the steep section (ideally containing the equivalence pH).
Explain unsuitable choices by where their range falls on the curve.
Watch out for
Choosing by colour, or always choosing an indicator with near 7.
Ammonia solution is titrated with hydrochloric acid. The equivalence point is at pH . Which indicator from the data book is the most suitable?
Common mistake
Choosing by colour
Students sometimes pick phenolphthalein for every titration because its pink is easy to see. The colours do not matter; the pH range does. Phenolphthalein in an ammonia–hydrochloric acid titration would not finish turning colourless until pH , which a titration reaches when only about of the ammonia has reacted, so the titre would be about too low.
Summary
An indicator is a weak acid (or weak base) whose conjugate forms have different colours: .
Acid shifts it to the colour; base shifts it to the colour.
At the two forms are equal; the visible change spans about .
The equivalence point is a mole ratio; the end point is the colour change. A good indicator makes them coincide.
Choose an indicator whose range lies within the steep part of the titration curve: phenolphthalein for weak acid–strong base, methyl red for strong acid–weak base.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.