Lesson 7 of 13 · 18 min
Strong, weak, concentrated and dilute
Classify acids by the protons they donate, name the strong and weak acids and bases, and separate strength from concentration using dissociation, pH, conductivity and rate.
What you will be able to do
- Describe an acid as a proton donor, and classify acids as monoprotic, diprotic or polyprotic.
- Name the strong acids and bases and the families of weak acids and bases in the syllabus.
- Discriminate between strong and weak, and between concentrated and dilute.
- Compare strong and weak acids by extent of dissociation, pH, electrical conductivity and rate of reaction, using data.
Hydrochloric acid in a swimming pool shop and the ethanoic acid in vinegar are both acids, yet you would only splash one of them on chips. At the same concentration, hydrochloric acid has a much lower pH, conducts electricity far better and fizzes far faster with magnesium. The difference is not how much acid is in the bottle but what happens to each molecule in water.
Definition
An acid is a proton donor
An acid is a substance that can donate a proton (a hydrogen ion, ). In water the proton is donated to a water molecule, forming the hydronium ion, :
and mean the same thing in equations and in ; a bare proton never exists on its own in water.
| Type | Protons donated per molecule | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Monoprotic | One | , , ethanoic acid (only the H on the group is acidic) |
| Diprotic | Two, one at a time | sulfuric acid , carbonic acid , oxalic (ethanedioic) acid |
| Polyprotic | More than one (triprotic: three) | phosphoric acid , citric acid |
Ethanoic acid, , has four hydrogen atoms. Why is it classified as monoprotic?
Key idea
Strong and weak
Strength is about the extent of ionisation (dissociation) in water.
- A strong acid ionises completely: , a one-way arrow. The strong acids to know are hydrochloric, nitric and sulfuric acid (sulfuric acid's first proton).
- A weak acid ionises only partly; an equilibrium lies well to the left: . Carboxylic acids (methanoic, ethanoic, citric) and carbonic acid are weak.
- Strong bases dissociate completely into hydroxide ions: the group 1 hydroxides (, , ) and barium hydroxide, .
- Weak bases accept protons from water only partly: ammonia and the amines, such as methanamine (methylamine), . For ammonia: .
Definition
Concentrated and dilute
Concentration is about how much acid or base is dissolved per litre. A concentrated solution has a lot of solute per litre; a dilute one has little.
The two ideas are independent. ethanoic acid is concentrated and weak; hydrochloric acid is dilute and strong.
Both beakers start at . Compare the particles, the pH, the bulb and the bubbles. Then make the strong acid dilute and the weak acid concentrated: can you make the two pH values match?
| Property | Hydrochloric acid (strong) | Ethanoic acid (weak) | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Extent of ionisation | about | Strength is the extent of ionisation | |
| Only ionised molecules release | |||
| pH | Lower means a higher pH | ||
| Electrical conductivity | High | Low | Conductivity depends on the concentration of mobile ions |
| Rate with magnesium or a carbonate | Fast, vigorous fizzing | Slow | Rate depends on , which sets the collision frequency |
| Moles of NaOH to neutralise | Neutralisation removes , so the weak acid keeps ionising until it is all used |
Common mistake
Strong is not concentrated
Do not use "strong" to mean "concentrated", or "weak" to mean "dilute". Strength is fixed for an acid; concentration depends on how much water you add. A dilute strong acid can have a higher pH than a concentrated weak acid: has pH , while ethanoic acid has pH .
Two acid solutions have the same pH. Solution X is hydrochloric acid and solution Y is ethanoic acid. Which statement is correct?
Worked example
Identify five solutions from pH and conductivity
Five unlabelled solutions are known to be hydrochloric acid, ethanoic acid, hydrochloric acid, ammonia and sodium hydroxide. A student measures each one.
| Solution | pH | Conductivity | Reaction with magnesium |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | low | slow bubbling | |
| Q | high | none | |
| R | high | rapid bubbling | |
| S | low | very slow bubbling | |
| T | low | none |
Identify each solution, and explain how P and S can have similar pH values and conductivities.
Step 1: Sort acids from bases
P, R and S have pH below 7 and react with magnesium: acids. Q and T have pH above 7: bases.
Step 2: Identify the bases
Q (pH , high conductivity) is fully dissociated: , pOH . Q is sodium hydroxide. T (pH , low conductivity) is only partly ionised: ammonia.
Step 3: Identify the strong concentrated acid
R has pH , so : fully ionised at . R is HCl.
Step 4: Separate P and S
S has pH , exactly what of a fully ionised acid gives: S is HCl, strong but dilute. P is ethanoic acid, weak but concentrated: only about ionised, so and pH .
pH and conductivity depend on the concentration of ions, which is set by both concentration and strength.
Step 5: Explain the similarity
Both P and S contain about of and of anions. In S it is because there is little acid, all ionised; in P because there is a lot of acid, only slightly ionised. Similar ion concentrations give similar pH, conductivity and rate.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
P ethanoic acid; Q sodium hydroxide; R HCl; S HCl; T ammonia. P (weak, concentrated) and S (strong, dilute) have similar and ion concentrations.
Method
pH below or above 7 separates acids from bases.
Compare pH with : equal means fully ionised (strong).
Low conductivity means few ions: weak, or dilute, or both.
Watch out for
Assuming the lowest conductivity must be the weak acid. A dilute strong acid can conduct as poorly.
Equal masses of magnesium ribbon (an excess) are added to of and to of . Compare the initial rate of reaction and the total volume of hydrogen produced.
Note
Investigating the properties of acids and bases
A fair comparison changes one thing at a time. To compare strength, use the same concentration of a strong and a weak acid at the same temperature, and measure:
- pH with a calibrated pH meter (better than universal indicator, which reads only to about ).
- Conductivity with a conductivity meter, or a simple circuit with a bulb or ammeter.
- Rate with identical pieces of magnesium ribbon or marble chips, timing the reaction or collecting the gas.
To compare concentration, dilute one acid ten-fold at a time and repeat the measurements.
Summary
Acids are proton donors; in water they form . Monoprotic acids donate one proton, diprotic two, polyprotic more than one.
Strong acids: , , . Strong bases: group 1 hydroxides and .
Weak acids: carboxylic acids and carbonic acid. Weak bases: ammonia and amines.
Strong or weak is the extent of ionisation; concentrated or dilute is the amount per litre.
At the same concentration a strong acid has a lower pH, higher conductivity and faster rate than a weak acid, but neutralises the same amount of base.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.