Lesson 4: Boiling points, vapour pressure and solubility
Explaining the boiling points of the group 16 hydrides
SkillsExplaining physical propertiesIdentifying intermolecular forces
Worked example
The boiling points of the group 16 hydrides at 101 kPa are: 100 °C, −60 °C, −41 °C and −2 °C. The graph shows the same data in kelvin. All four molecules are bent.
(a) Explain the trend from to .
(b) Explain why water does not follow the trend.
(c) Predict what the boiling point of water would be if it followed the trend, and comment on what this means for life on Earth.
Step 1: Identify the forces in , and
Each is bent with polar bonds, so it has dipole–dipole attractions as well as dispersion forces. S, Se and Te are not N, O or F, so none of them forms hydrogen bonds.
Step 2: Explain the trend (a)
Down the group the molecules have more electrons (18, 36, 54), so their electron clouds are more easily distorted and dispersion forces get stronger. The bonds do not become more polar (S–H and Se–H differ by , Te–H by only ), so the rise is due to dispersion forces. More energy is needed to separate the molecules, so boiling points rise from −60 °C to −2 °C.
The trend continues even though the dipoles weaken, which shows dispersion forces dominate for these molecules.
Step 3: Explain water (b)
In water, H is bonded to O, which is small and highly electronegative (3.4). Each molecule can form hydrogen bonds to its neighbours through its two H atoms and two lone pairs. These are much stronger than the dipole–dipole and dispersion forces in the other hydrides, so far more energy is needed to separate water molecules.
Step 4: Extrapolate the trend (c)
Extending the trend of the heavier hydrides back to period 2 (the dashed line continues the slope from to ) gives roughly 190–195 K, about −80 °C. A straight line of best fit through all three heavier hydrides is steeper and gives about 180 K, so anything from about −100 °C to −70 °C is a sensible estimate.
Step 5: Comment
Without hydrogen bonding, water would be a gas at every temperature found on Earth's surface. There would be no liquid oceans, rivers or water inside cells, so life as we know it could not exist.
Answer
(a) Down the group the number of electrons increases, so dispersion forces get stronger and boiling points rise. (b) Water molecules form hydrogen bonds with each other (H bonded to O), which are much stronger than the forces between the other hydrides' molecules. (c) About −80 °C (−100 °C to −70 °C); water would be a gas at Earth's surface temperatures and there would be no liquid water for life.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Boiling points of the group 16 hydrides, in kelvin. The dashed line extends the trend of the heavier hydrides back to period 2.
Method
Explain a trend down a group with the number of electrons and dispersion forces.
Explain an exception by identifying a different, stronger force.
Extrapolate a trend line carefully and state the estimate as approximate.
Watch out for
Explaining the rise down the group with "stronger dipoles". The bonds actually become less polar.
Saying water's O–H bonds are stronger. Boiling does not break them.