Lesson 5: How chromatography separates a mixture
Explaining a paper chromatography separation
SkillHow chromatography separates
Worked example
A student spots a mixture of two dyes on chromatography paper and develops it with water. Dye A forms many hydrogen bonds; dye B is much less polar but still dissolves in water. After 20 minutes, dye B has moved much further than dye A.
(a) Identify the stationary and mobile phases.
(b) Explain why the dyes separated, and why dye B moved further.
(c) Predict how the separation would change if the student used a less polar solvent such as ethanol.
Step 1: Identify the phases (a)
The stationary phase is the paper: cellulose fibres with water held on them. The mobile phase is the solvent, water, which rises up the paper by capillary action.
Step 2: Describe what each dye molecule does
Each dye molecule constantly switches between being adsorbed onto the cellulose and being dissolved in the moving solvent. It only moves up the paper while it is dissolved.
Step 3: Explain the separation (b)
Cellulose is covered in O–H groups. Dye A forms many hydrogen bonds, so it is strongly attracted to the cellulose and spends much of its time adsorbed: it moves slowly. Dye B is less polar, so it is attracted less strongly to the cellulose and spends more of its time dissolved in the mobile phase: it moves further.
The components separate because they divide their time between the two phases differently. If both dyes were attracted equally they would travel together.
Step 4: Predict the effect of ethanol (c)
A less polar solvent dissolves the less polar dye B well, but dissolves the strongly hydrogen-bonding dye A less well, so A would spend even more time on the paper. Dye A would move less (or stay near the baseline) while B still moves, so the spots would end up further apart.
Answer
(a) Stationary: cellulose paper; mobile: water. (b) Dye A is held more strongly by hydrogen bonds to the polar cellulose, so it spends more time adsorbed and moves less; dye B is attracted less to the paper and more to the mobile phase, so it moves further. (c) In ethanol, dye A would move even less relative to dye B, so the separation would increase.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Name both phases.
Compare each component's attraction to the stationary phase with its solubility in the mobile phase.
More time in the mobile phase means further travel.
Watch out for
Saying dye B moved further because its molecules are lighter. Separation depends on attractions, not mass.
Forgetting that the paper (cellulose) is the stationary phase, not the solvent.