Lesson 2: Separating mixtures
Evaluating a salt recovery
SkillsSeparating mixturesMelting point and density data
Worked example
Crust scraped from the edge of a dry salt lake is a mixture of sodium chloride with insoluble sand and clay. A student dissolved of the crust in water, filtered it, and evaporated the filtrate to dryness. They recorded:
| Mass (g) | |
|---|---|
| Salt-lake crust used | 20.00 |
| Salt recovered | 5.86 |
| Residue on the filter paper (weighed straight after filtering) | 14.62 |
(a) Calculate the percentage of salt in the crust from these results.
(b) The two products total more than 20.00 g. Explain the most likely cause.
(c) The student saw salt crystals spitting out of the basin during evaporation. Explain the effect on the result in (a), and suggest two improvements to the method.
Step 1: Calculate the percentage of salt
Step 2: Compare the total with the starting mass
, which is more than the 20.00 g used. Mass cannot be created, so something extra was weighed.
Step 3: Find the cause
The residue was weighed straight after filtering, while it was still wet. Its mass includes water (and some salt solution soaked into it), so 14.62 g is too high.
Water clinging to the residue is the only extra substance that could add mass. Spitting or lost salt would make the total smaller, not larger.
Step 4: Explain the effect of spitting
Salt that spits out of the basin is lost, so the mass of salt recovered is too small and 29.3 % is an underestimate. This is a systematic error: it always lowers the result.
Step 5: Suggest improvements
Stop heating when crystals first appear and let the rest of the water evaporate slowly (or cover the basin loosely), so no salt spits out. Wash the residue with a little distilled water to rinse out trapped salt solution, then dry it in an oven to constant mass before weighing.
Answer
(a) 29.3 % salt.
(b) The residue was weighed wet: the water (and salt solution) still in it added mass, so the total, 20.48 g, exceeds 20.00 g.
(c) Salt lost by spitting makes the recovered mass, and so the 29.3 %, too low. Improvements: heat gently and stop when crystals form, finishing the evaporation slowly; wash the residue and dry it to constant mass before weighing.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Percentage = part ÷ whole × 100 %.
Check whether the products add up to the starting mass; an excess means something extra was weighed.
For each error, give its direction (too high or too low) and an improvement that removes the cause.
Watch out for
Writing "human error" or "inaccurate measurements" instead of naming the cause and its direction.
Suggesting "repeat the experiment" for a systematic error. Repeats reduce random error; they do not stop salt spitting.