Lesson 5: Classifying substances from property data

Is sugar ionic? Evaluating a student's claim

SkillClassifying substances from data

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology free

A student tested solids and their solutions (made with tap water) with a conductivity tester containing an ammeter.

TestCurrent (A)
Solid sugar (sucrose)0.00
Sugar dissolved in tap water0.02
Solid sodium chloride0.00
Sodium chloride dissolved in tap water0.85

The student concluded: "Sugar and sodium chloride are both ionic, because both solutions conducted." Sugar melts (and decomposes) at about 186 °C.

Evaluate the student's conclusion and suggest how to improve the investigation.

1 of 5 steps
  1. Step 1: Look at the size of the currents

    The sugar solution's current (0.02 A) is about 40 times smaller than the salt solution's (0.85 A). "Both conducted" hides a huge difference.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Compare the sizes of results, not just yes or no.

  2. Look for a missing control or an uncontrolled variable.

  3. Bring in all the evidence (melting point too).

  4. Judge: supported, partly supported or not supported, and why.

  5. Suggest specific improvements.

Watch out for

  • Agreeing that sugar is ionic because "the ammeter moved".

  • Suggesting only "repeat the experiment", which would repeat the same flaw.

Save your progress with a free account