Lesson 5: Classifying substances from property data
Is sugar ionic? Evaluating a student's claim
SkillClassifying substances from data
Worked example
A student tested solids and their solutions (made with tap water) with a conductivity tester containing an ammeter.
| Test | Current (A) |
|---|---|
| Solid sugar (sucrose) | 0.00 |
| Sugar dissolved in tap water | 0.02 |
| Solid sodium chloride | 0.00 |
| Sodium chloride dissolved in tap water | 0.85 |
The student concluded: "Sugar and sodium chloride are both ionic, because both solutions conducted." Sugar melts (and decomposes) at about 186 °C.
Evaluate the student's conclusion and suggest how to improve the investigation.
Step 1: Look at the size of the currents
The sugar solution's current (0.02 A) is about 40 times smaller than the salt solution's (0.85 A). "Both conducted" hides a huge difference.
Step 2: Identify the flaw in the method
Tap water contains dissolved ions (such as , and ), so it conducts slightly on its own. No control was tested, so the small current with sugar could come entirely from the tap water.
Without a control you cannot tell what part of a result is caused by the variable you are testing.
Step 3: Use the other evidence
Sugar melts at a low temperature (about 186 °C), which fits a covalent molecular substance with weak forces between molecules, not an ionic lattice (sodium chloride melts at 801 °C).
Step 4: Judge the conclusion
The conclusion is valid for sodium chloride (a large current in solution, none as a solid) but not supported for sugar. The evidence points to sugar being covalent molecular: its solution contains neutral molecules, not ions.
Step 5: Suggest improvements
Use deionised water to make the solutions, and test the deionised water alone as a control; rinse the electrodes with deionised water between tests; keep the concentration and electrode spacing the same for each solution; repeat each test.
Answer
The conclusion is only partly valid. Sodium chloride's results (0.00 A as a solid, 0.85 A in solution) support ionic bonding. Sugar's tiny current (0.02 A) is most likely due to ions already in the tap water, since no control was tested; with its low melting point, the evidence shows sugar is covalent molecular. Improve by using deionised water with a deionised-water control, rinsing electrodes between tests and controlling concentration.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare the sizes of results, not just yes or no.
Look for a missing control or an uncontrolled variable.
Bring in all the evidence (melting point too).
Judge: supported, partly supported or not supported, and why.
Suggest specific improvements.
Watch out for
Agreeing that sugar is ionic because "the ammeter moved".
Suggesting only "repeat the experiment", which would repeat the same flaw.