Lesson 5: Classifying substances from property data
Classifying five solids from their properties
SkillClassifying substances from data
Worked example
Determine the structure and bonding of each solid, giving the evidence for each.
| Solid | Melting point (°C) | Conducts as solid | Conducts as liquid or in water | Other observations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 801 | no | yes (molten and in water) | brittle crystals, dissolves in water |
| B | 1085 | yes | yes (molten) | malleable, insoluble |
| C | 114 | no | no | soft, dissolves in hexane but barely in water |
| D | about 1700 | no | no (molten) | very hard, insoluble in water and hexane |
| E | above 3500 | yes | — | soft and slippery, black, insoluble |
Step 1: A: ionic lattice
High melting point; conducts only when molten or dissolved, so its charged particles are ions that are fixed in the solid and free in the liquid. Brittle and water-soluble fit too. (Sodium chloride.)
Step 2: B: metallic lattice
Conducts as a solid and as a liquid, so it has delocalised electrons; malleable. (Copper.)
Step 3: C: covalent molecular
Low melting point, so only weak forces between molecules are overcome; never conducts, so no mobile charged particles; soft. (Iodine.)
Step 4: D: giant covalent network
Very high melting point, so strong bonds throughout; but it never conducts, even molten, so it has no ions or delocalised electrons. Very hard and insoluble. (Silicon dioxide.)
Step 5: E: giant covalent network with delocalised electrons
Melts only above 3500 °C, so strong covalent bonds throughout, yet it conducts as a solid, is soft and slippery, and is black: graphite, whose layers slide and whose delocalised electrons move along the layers.
E is the trap. Conducting as a solid suggests a metal, but a soft, slippery black solid that is not malleable and melts above 3500 °C fits graphite.
Answer
A ionic (sodium chloride); B metallic (copper); C covalent molecular (iodine); D giant covalent network (silicon dioxide); E giant covalent network, graphite.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Solid conductivity: yes, metallic (or graphite).
Then melting point: low, covalent molecular.
High: conducts molten or in water, ionic; never conducts, covalent network.
Use the other observations to confirm or catch exceptions.
Watch out for
Calling E a metal because it conducts. Check the other columns.
Calling D ionic because of its high melting point.