Lesson 13 of 14 · 18 min
Recombinant DNA and genetic modification
Describe how restriction enzymes, plasmids and DNA ligase are used to make recombinant DNA, and weigh the benefits and risks of transgenic crops and CRISPR genome editing.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how restriction enzymes cut DNA at recognition sequences, leaving sticky or blunt ends.
- Describe the steps in making a recombinant plasmid and getting bacteria to express a human gene.
- Describe transgenic crops and the ecological concerns about them.
- Describe how CRISPR–Cas9 edits a genome, and evaluate its safety and efficacy.
Before 1982, people with type 1 diabetes injected insulin extracted from the pancreases of slaughtered cattle and pigs. Since then, almost all insulin has been made by bacteria or yeast carrying a copy of the human insulin gene. Getting a human gene to work in a bacterium needs three tools: an enzyme that cuts DNA at a chosen place, a carrier to get the gene into the cell, and an enzyme to join the pieces. The result is recombinant DNA: DNA that combines sequences from two different sources.
Definition
Restriction enzymes
A restriction enzyme (restriction endonuclease) cuts both strands of DNA at a specific recognition sequence, usually 4 to 8 base pairs long. Bacteria make them to cut up the DNA of invading viruses.
Most recognition sequences are palindromic: they read the same 5′→3′ on both strands. EcoRI recognises 5′-GAATTC-3′ and cuts between G and A on each strand. Because the cuts are staggered, each end has a short single-stranded overhang, AATT: a sticky end. Some enzymes, such as SmaI (CCC↓GGG), cut straight across, leaving blunt ends.
Pick an enzyme to light up its recognition sites, then cut. Compare the staggered cut of a sticky-end enzyme with a blunt cut.
Why must the plasmid and the gene be cut with the same restriction enzyme?
A recombinant plasmid carrying an inserted gene.
Making a recombinant plasmid
Get the gene and the vector
Isolate the gene of interest, and plasmids from bacteria. Plasmids make good vectors (carriers): they replicate on their own inside bacteria, and many carry an antibiotic-resistance gene that can be used to find the bacteria that took them up. For a human gene, a copy without introns is made from its mRNA using reverse transcriptase, because bacteria cannot splice out introns.
Cut both with the same restriction enzyme
This opens the plasmid at its one recognition site and cuts the gene out, leaving matching sticky ends.
Mix them
The complementary sticky ends of the gene and the opened plasmid pair up by hydrogen bonds.
Seal with DNA ligase
DNA ligase forms phosphodiester bonds in the sugar–phosphate backbone, joining the gene into the plasmid permanently: a recombinant plasmid.
Transform the bacteria
Bacteria are made to take up the plasmids, for example by a brief heat shock in calcium chloride. Only a small fraction succeed.
Select and grow
The bacteria are grown on agar containing the antibiotic. Only those carrying a plasmid (with its resistance gene) survive. They are tested to find those with the gene inserted, then grown in large fermenters, where they make the protein, which is purified.
Step through cutting, annealing, ligation, transformation, selection and expression.
Worked example
Cutting with EcoRI and making a recombinant plasmid
EcoRI recognises 5′-GAATTC-3′ and cuts between G and A.
(a) Show the ends left when EcoRI cuts the double-stranded sequence 5′-…GAATTC…-3′. (b) A biotechnologist wants Escherichia coli to make a human enzyme. Explain why she inserts a DNA copy made from the enzyme's mRNA, not the gene cut from a chromosome. (c) Outline how the recombinant bacteria are made and identified, naming the role of each tool.
Step 1: Both strands
Top
5′-…G AATTC…-3′, bottom3′-…CTTAA G…-5′. The site is palindromic: the bottom strand also reads GAATTC 5′→3′.Step 2: The cut
Cutting between G and A on both strands leaves two pieces, each with a single-stranded
5′-AATToverhang: sticky ends, complementary to each other.Step 3: Why a copy from mRNA
The human gene contains introns. Bacteria have no spliceosomes, so they cannot remove introns, and would make the wrong protein. A DNA copy made from mature mRNA by reverse transcriptase contains only the exons.
Step 4: Cut and join
Cut the plasmid (at its single EcoRI site) and the DNA copy (with EcoRI sites at its ends) with EcoRI, so both have complementary AATT sticky ends. Mixed, the ends base-pair; DNA ligase seals the backbone with phosphodiester bonds.
Step 5: Transform and select
Bacteria take up plasmids (transformation, for example by heat shock). Grown on agar with the antibiotic, only bacteria carrying a plasmid, with its resistance gene, survive; colonies are then tested for the inserted gene and for the enzyme.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Staggered ends with 5′-AATT single-stranded overhangs. (b) Bacteria cannot splice introns out, so the copy must contain only exons. (c) Cut plasmid and gene with EcoRI (complementary sticky ends), join with DNA ligase, transform bacteria, select on the antibiotic, screen for the insert.
Method
Write both strands and mark the cut on each.
Explain each tool by what it does to the DNA: cut, pair, seal, carry, select.
Watch out for
Cutting the bottom strand at the same position as the top, which would give blunt ends.
Saying DNA ligase makes the sticky ends pair (hydrogen bonds do that; ligase seals the backbone).
Put these steps for making bacteria that produce human growth hormone in order.
Transgenic organisms. An organism carrying a gene from another species is transgenic. Plants are usually transformed with the bacterium Agrobacterium tumefaciens, which naturally transfers part of a plasmid into plant cells. Many transgenic crops are on the market:
- Insect-resistant crops carry a gene from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) for a protein toxic to certain insect larvae. Almost all cotton grown in Australia is Bt cotton, which has greatly reduced insecticide spraying.
- Herbicide-tolerant crops, such as some canola, survive a herbicide (often glyphosate) that kills the weeds around them.
- Disease-resistant crops: in 2024 Australia's Gene Technology Regulator licensed QCAV-4 for commercial growing, and Food Standards Australia New Zealand approved it as food. It is a Cavendish banana developed at the Queensland University of Technology with a resistance gene (RGA2) from a wild banana, and it resists Panama disease tropical race 4, a soil fungus that threatens banana growing worldwide. QUT has said it is a safety net for the industry rather than a banana it plans to sell now.
- Nutrient-enhanced crops, such as Golden Rice, which makes β-carotene (provitamin A).
Key idea
The ecological concerns
- Non-target organisms: a toxin or a changed farm system may harm species other than the pest, such as pollinators or the predators of pests.
- Faster evolution of resistance: when a whole region grows Bt crops or sprays one herbicide, pests or weeds with resistance alleles have a strong selective advantage. Glyphosate-resistant weeds and Bt-resistant insects have both appeared. Farmers slow this with refuges (areas of non-Bt plants where non-resistant insects survive and breed) and by rotating herbicides.
- Gene flow to weeds: pollen can carry a transgene to a wild relative that can cross with the crop, possibly creating herbicide-tolerant "super weeds". Canola, which crosses with some weedy relatives, is the usual example.
In Australia, the Office of the Gene Technology Regulator assesses the risks of each GM organism before release, and Food Standards Australia New Zealand assesses GM foods.
A district grows only Bt cotton for ten years. Explain why the cotton bollworm population may become resistant to the Bt toxin, and how a refuge of non-Bt cotton slows this.
Genome editing with CRISPR–Cas9. Recombinant DNA adds a gene; genome editing changes an organism's own DNA at a chosen place. CRISPR–Cas9 comes from a bacterial defence against viruses. It has two parts:
- a guide RNA, about 20 bases long, made to be complementary to the target sequence in the genome;
- Cas9, an enzyme that cuts both strands of DNA where the guide RNA has base-paired.
The cell repairs the cut. Repair often adds or deletes a few bases, which can knock out a gene with a frameshift; or, if a DNA template is supplied, the cell can copy a new sequence into the gap, correcting or inserting a sequence.
History
Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer Doudna
In 2012 Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer A Doudna showed that the CRISPR–Cas9 system of the bacterium Streptococcus pyogenes could be programmed with a guide RNA to cut any chosen DNA sequence in a test tube. Within months other groups were editing human and mouse cells with it. Charpentier and Doudna shared the 2020 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, the first science Nobel awarded to two women with no male co-laureate.
Note
Investigating safety and efficacy
When you evaluate a gene technology, separate efficacy (does it do what is claimed: how often is the target edited, how much does the trait or the disease improve?) from safety (what else happens?). For CRISPR the main safety questions are off-target edits (cuts at similar sequences elsewhere), mosaicism (only some cells edited) and unintended large deletions. Editing somatic cells affects only the patient, like the 2023 treatment for sickle-cell disease; editing embryos or gametes would be inherited, and in 2018 the birth of the first gene-edited babies in China was widely condemned and the scientist responsible was jailed. Use primary sources and regulators' reports, note who funded a study, and give evidence on both sides.
Summary
Restriction enzymes cut DNA at palindromic recognition sequences, leaving sticky (staggered) or blunt ends.
Cutting a plasmid and a gene with the same enzyme gives complementary sticky ends that pair up.
DNA ligase seals the sugar–phosphate backbone with phosphodiester bonds, making recombinant DNA.
Bacteria are transformed with the recombinant plasmid and selected with an antibiotic-resistance marker; a gene without introns is used.
Transgenic crops resist insects (Bt), herbicides or disease; concerns are non-target effects, faster evolution of resistance and gene flow to weeds.
CRISPR–Cas9 uses a guide RNA to direct Cas9 to cut a chosen sequence; Charpentier and Doudna shared the 2020 Nobel Prize in Chemistry.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.