Lesson 6 of 14 · 18 min
Regulating gene expression
Explain how chemical tags on DNA and histones, and transcription factors at the promoter, switch genes on and off in response to signals and during differentiation, and how HOX genes lay out the body plan.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why cells with the same genome can be different: differential gene expression.
- Describe how DNA methylation and histone acetylation change chromatin between heterochromatin and euchromatin.
- Explain how transcription factors binding at a promoter control transcription, including in response to environmental signals.
- Explain how HOX genes, a family of transcription factors, give each body region its identity.
A neuron and a liver cell from the same person carry identical DNA. The neuron makes neurotransmitters and never makes the liver's clotting proteins; the liver cell does the reverse. They differ because each expresses a different set of its genes. Some genes, such as those for ribosome proteins or the enzymes of respiration, are on in almost every cell; many others are switched on only in some cells, at some times, or in response to a signal.
Cells control gene expression at several levels. The syllabus focuses on two that act on transcription: how tightly the DNA is packed, and which proteins bind to a gene's promoter.
Definition
Euchromatin and heterochromatin
- Euchromatin is loosely packed chromatin. RNA polymerase and transcription factors can reach its DNA, so its genes can be transcribed.
- Heterochromatin is tightly packed chromatin, with the nucleosomes pressed together. The DNA is inaccessible, so its genes are silenced.
Chemical tags change the packing. Small chemical groups added to DNA or to histones change how tightly chromatin is packed, without changing the base sequence:
- DNA methylation: methyl groups () are added to cytosine bases, often in and around a gene's promoter. Methylated DNA attracts proteins that condense the chromatin into heterochromatin and blocks transcription factors from binding. More methylation, less transcription.
- Histone acetylation: acetyl groups are added to the tails of histone proteins. This weakens the attraction between the positive histones and the negative DNA, loosening the chromatin into euchromatin. More acetylation, more transcription. Removing acetyl groups (deacetylation) packs it tight again.
These tags are copied to daughter cells when a cell divides, so a liver cell's descendants stay liver cells. Changes in gene expression that are passed on through cell division without a change in the DNA sequence are called epigenetic. Diet, stress, toxins and age can all change the tags.
Add and remove methyl groups on the DNA and acetyl groups on the histones. Watch the nucleosomes pack and unpack, and whether RNA polymerase can reach the promoter.
A gene's promoter becomes heavily methylated and the histones nearby lose their acetyl groups. What is the most likely result?
Note
One X switched off
Females have two X chromosomes and males one, yet both make the same amount of most X-linked proteins. Early in a female embryo, each cell condenses one of its two X chromosomes, at random, into heterochromatin (a Barr body), and its descendants keep the same one switched off. A tortoiseshell cat's patches show this: the coat-colour gene is on the X, and in each patch a different X is active.
Transcription factors. RNA polymerase cannot find and bind a promoter on its own in eukaryotes. Transcription factors are proteins that bind to specific DNA sequences in or near a gene's promoter and recruit (or block) RNA polymerase.
- General transcription factors are needed at every promoter.
- Specific transcription factors are made only in some cells or only after a signal. Activators bind and increase transcription of their target genes; repressors bind and decrease it.
A gene is transcribed only when the right combination of factors is present. A cell's identity comes from which transcription factors it makes: a precursor cell that starts making the factor MyoD, for example, switches on a cascade of muscle genes and becomes a muscle cell. Transcription factors often switch on genes for other transcription factors, so one signal can set off a whole program of differentiation.
Responding to the environment. Many signals act by activating a transcription factor:
- Hormones. A steroid hormone such as oestrogen or testosterone diffuses through the plasma membrane and binds a receptor protein in the cell. The hormone–receptor complex is a transcription factor: it enters the nucleus and binds to the promoters of target genes.
- Temperature. A sudden rise in temperature activates heat-shock transcription factors, which switch on genes for heat-shock proteins that refold damaged proteins.
- Nutrients in bacteria. An Escherichia coli cell makes the enzymes for digesting lactose only when lactose is present: without it, a repressor protein sits on the DNA beside the promoter and blocks RNA polymerase; lactose binds the repressor and releases it.
Each cell type has the same genes but makes different transcription factors. Change the cell and the signal, and watch which promoters are bound.
Muscle cells and skin cells from the same person have identical DNA. Explain, in terms of gene expression, why they make different proteins.
HOX genes. How does a developing embryo know where to put a head, wings or legs? In animals, the identity of each region along the head-to-tail axis is set by HOX genes, a family of genes coding for transcription factors.
- Each HOX gene contains a 180-base-pair sequence, the homeobox, coding for a 60-amino-acid region (the homeodomain) that binds DNA. That makes each HOX protein a transcription factor that switches on or off the many genes that build a particular body part.
- HOX genes sit in clusters, and their order along the chromosome matches the order of the body regions they control, from head to tail. Fruit flies have eight HOX genes, in two groups on the same chromosome; humans have 39, in four clusters on four chromosomes.
- A HOX gene expressed in the wrong place gives a body part the wrong identity. In the fruit fly mutant Antennapedia, legs grow where antennae should be; in bithorax mutants the third thoracic segment develops like the second, giving a fly with four wings instead of two wings and two small balancing organs (halteres).
Tap each HOX gene to see which segment it controls. The genes run along the chromosome in the same order as the segments they control.
Worked example
Explaining a four-winged fly
Normal fruit flies have two wings on the second thoracic segment (T2) and two small halteres (balancing organs) on the third (T3). The HOX gene Ultrabithorax (Ubx) is normally expressed in T3 but not T2. Flies with mutations that stop Ubx being expressed in T3 have four wings.
Explain how the absence of one HOX gene's expression produces a whole extra pair of wings, and why this shows HOX genes regulate morphology.
Step 1: What Ubx is
Ubx codes for a transcription factor with a homeodomain that binds DNA at the promoters of many target genes.
Step 2: What it does in T3
In normal T3 cells, Ubx protein represses genes needed for wing development and activates genes that build a haltere, so T3 develops its own identity.
One transcription factor controls a whole set of downstream genes, so it controls the development of an entire structure.
Step 3: Without Ubx in T3
With no Ubx protein, the wing genes in T3 are not repressed. T3 cells follow the T2 program (the "default" without Ubx) and develop wings instead of halteres: four wings.
Step 4: Why this shows regulation of morphology
No wing genes were added or changed; the same genes were simply switched on in a different place. A HOX gene determines a segment's identity by controlling which genes are expressed there, so it shapes the body plan.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Ubx is a transcription factor that normally switches off wing-development genes and switches on haltere genes in T3. Without it, T3 expresses the T2 (wing) program and grows wings. HOX genes regulate morphology by controlling which sets of genes are expressed in each segment.
Method
Identify the HOX protein as a transcription factor.
Say which target genes it switches on or off, and where.
Explain the mutant as the wrong program running in a segment.
Watch out for
Saying the mutation "adds wing genes".
Forgetting that the HOX protein acts by binding DNA (it is a transcription factor).
History
Lewis, Nüsslein-Volhard and Wieschaus
Edward B Lewis spent decades studying flies with homeotic mutations such as bithorax, and showed that the genes controlling segment identity lie in clusters in the same order as the body segments. Christiane Nüsslein-Volhard and Eric F Wieschaus, working together in Heidelberg from 1978, mutated thousands of fruit flies and sorted the embryos by their defects, finding the genes that set up the body's axis and its segments. The three shared the 1995 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for their discoveries about the genetic control of early embryonic development. Genes like the ones they found turned out to control development in almost all animals, humans included.
Which observation best supports the claim that HOX genes control body plans in a similar way across very different animals?
Note
Epigenetics in medicine
Because epigenetic tags can be removed, some can be targeted by drugs. Cancer cells often silence tumour-suppressor genes by methylating their promoters. Azacitidine, which blocks DNA methylation, is used to treat some blood cancers, and drugs that block histone deacetylation are used for some lymphomas. Methylation patterns in blood are also being studied as tests for early cancer.
Summary
Cells with the same genome differ because they express different genes (differential gene expression).
Euchromatin is loose and its genes can be transcribed; heterochromatin is condensed and its genes are silenced.
DNA methylation condenses chromatin and silences genes; histone acetylation loosens it and allows transcription.
Epigenetic tags are passed on in cell division and can change with the environment, without changing the DNA sequence.
Transcription factors bind at promoters to switch transcription up (activators) or down (repressors), and signals such as hormones act through them.
HOX genes code for transcription factors (with a DNA-binding homeodomain) that give each region along the body its identity; they are clustered in head-to-tail order.
Lewis, Nüsslein-Volhard and Wieschaus shared the 1995 Nobel Prize for the genetic control of development.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.