Lesson 4: Selection pressures and allele frequency data
Positive and negative selection for a resistance allele
SkillsAnalysing selection dataCalculating allele frequencies
Worked example
Diamondback moths on a farm were genotyped for an insecticide-resistance gene ( resistant, dominant; susceptible). The farm sprayed for four years, then stopped.
| Year | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (spraying starts) | 1 | 6 | 193 |
| 4 (spraying stops) | 72 | 88 | 40 |
| 10 | 58 | 92 | 50 |
Use the data to determine the effect of spraying on the moth population, and whether selection on was positive or negative before and after spraying stopped.
Step 1: Frequency of in each year
Each sample has , so . Year 0: . Year 4: . Year 10: .
Step 2: Changes
Years 0–4: . Years 4–10: .
Step 3: Interpret the spraying period
While spraying, the frequency of rose sharply: positive selection for (and negative selection against ). Susceptible moths were killed; moths carrying survived and bred.
Step 4: Interpret after spraying
After spraying stopped, fell slightly and slowly: weak negative selection against , suggesting resistance has a small cost when no insecticide is present.
Step 5: Comment on the conclusion
The trend is clear, but each figure is one sample of 200 from one farm. Repeated samples or more farms would show whether the small fall after year 4 is real or sampling variation.
Answer
The frequency of rose from 0.02 to 0.58 during spraying (positive selection for ), then fell to 0.52 over six years without spraying (weak negative selection against ). Spraying was a strong selection pressure for resistance.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate the allele frequency for each sample.
Find the change between samples and its sign.
Rise = positive selection for that allele; fall = negative selection.
Link each change to the selection pressure and comment on reliability.
Watch out for
Comparing the number of moths alone, which ignores the alleles in heterozygotes.
Calling the slow fall after spraying "no selection" without looking at the data.