Lesson 4: Selection pressures and allele frequency data
Analyse a bead simulation of selection
SkillsAnalysing selection dataCalculating allele frequencies
Worked example
A class models selection against a recessive phenotype. Red beads are allele and white beads allele . Each generation, 50 "individuals" (pairs of beads) are drawn; every individual is removed before the survivors' beads are used to make the next generation. The results are in the table in the lesson (generation 0: 13 , 25 , 12 ; generation 4: 34 , 15 , 1 ).
(a) Calculate the frequency of in generations 0 and 4. (b) Describe the trend in the frequency of over the five generations (0.49, 0.33, 0.25, 0.21, 0.17). (c) Explain why is not eliminated. (d) Suggest one way to improve the reliability of the results.
Step 1: Frequency of in generation 0
. Copies of : . Frequency .
Step 2: Frequency of in generation 4
Copies of : . Frequency .
Step 3: Describe the trend
The frequency of falls every generation, from 0.49 to 0.17, but by less each time: , , , . Selection against is negative selection on allele .
Step 4: Explain why persists
Only individuals are removed. Most remaining alleles are in heterozygotes, which survive because is recessive, so they pass on.
Step 5: Improve reliability
Drawing 50 pairs gives large chance variation (drift). Pool the results of several groups, or repeat the simulation several times and average the frequencies each generation; or use a computer simulation to run many more generations and replicates.
Answer
(a) 0.49 and 0.17. (b) It falls each generation, rapidly at first then more slowly. (c) Heterozygotes carry but survive, so selection cannot reach those copies. (d) Repeat the simulation (or pool class results) and average, to reduce the effect of chance.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Count alleles out of for each generation.
Describe the direction and the rate of change, with numbers.
Link the shape to dominance (recessive alleles hide in heterozygotes).
Reliability: repeats and larger samples reduce random error.
Watch out for
Expecting to reach 0 within a few generations.
Confusing reliability (repeatable results) with validity (testing what you meant to test).