Lesson 3: Natural selection and the three types of selection
Explain the evolution of antibiotic resistance
SkillsNatural selection and its typesAnalysing selection data
Worked example
A patient with a Staphylococcus aureus infection is treated with an antibiotic. Within the patient, the infection at first clears, then returns, and the returning bacteria are resistant to the antibiotic. Explain, using the theory of natural selection, how the bacterial population became resistant. (4 marks)
Step 1: Variation already existed
Before treatment, the bacterial population varied. A few bacteria carried an allele for resistance, produced earlier by a random mutation (or gained from another bacterium on a plasmid).
The resistance did not arise because of the antibiotic. It was already present at low frequency.
Step 2: The selection pressure
The antibiotic is the selection pressure: it kills susceptible bacteria.
Step 3: Differential survival and reproduction
Resistant bacteria survived and divided, while most susceptible bacteria died, so the resistant bacteria had greater fitness.
Step 4: Inheritance
Bacteria reproduce by binary fission, so the daughter cells inherit the resistance allele.
Step 5: Change in allele frequency
Over many generations (bacteria can divide every 30 minutes or so), the frequency of the resistance allele rose until almost the whole population was resistant.
Answer
A random mutation had already given a few bacteria a resistance allele. The antibiotic killed susceptible bacteria (selection pressure), while resistant ones survived and reproduced, passing the allele to their offspring. Over many generations the resistance allele frequency rose until the population was resistant.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Variation from mutation, before the pressure.
Selection pressure kills or reduces reproduction of some phenotypes.
Favoured individuals survive, reproduce and pass on the allele.
Allele frequency rises over generations.
Watch out for
Writing "the bacteria became resistant to survive" or "the antibiotic caused the mutation".
Saying the patient became resistant. The bacterial population evolved.