Lesson 5: Divergent, convergent, parallel and coevolution
Rabbits and myxoma virus as coevolution
SkillsPatterns of macroevolutionAnalysing selection data
Worked example
Myxoma virus was released in Australia in 1950 to control European rabbits. Biologists sampled the virus in the field and tested wild rabbits with a standard strain of the virus each year. The data below are illustrative, following the pattern Frank Fenner's team recorded.
| Year | Field samples that were the most lethal strain (%) | Wild rabbits killed by the standard test strain (%) |
|---|---|---|
| 1951 | 100 | 90 |
| 1953 | 30 | 85 |
| 1955 | 10 | 60 |
| 1958 | 5 | 30 |
The virus is spread between rabbits by mosquitoes, which bite live rabbits. Use the data to explain why this is an example of coevolution. (5 marks)
Step 1: Describe the change in the virus
The most lethal strain fell from 100 % of field samples in 1951 to 5 % by 1958: less lethal strains took over.
Step 2: Explain the selection on the virus
A rabbit infected with a highly lethal strain dies quickly, so few mosquitoes bite it and the strain spreads less. A rabbit with a less lethal strain lives longer and is bitten more, so that strain is transmitted to more rabbits. Less lethal strains had higher fitness: selection favoured them.
Step 3: Describe the change in the rabbits
The percentage of wild rabbits killed by the same standard strain fell from 90 % to 30 %, so the rabbits themselves became more resistant.
Using a standard test strain separates the change in the rabbits from the change in the virus.
Step 4: Explain the selection on the rabbits
The virus was a selection pressure. Rabbits that carried alleles giving some resistance survived and bred more, so the frequency of resistance alleles in the rabbit population rose.
Step 5: Link the two
Each species was a selection pressure on the other and both changed in response: coevolution. As rabbits become more resistant, selection on the virus changes again, which is why later work found new, more virulent forms evolving.
Answer
Selection favoured less lethal virus strains (5 % most-lethal by 1958) because longer-lived rabbits spread more virus via mosquitoes; at the same time the virus selected for resistant rabbits (deaths from the standard strain fell from 90 % to 30 %). Each species acted as a selection pressure on the other and both evolved: coevolution.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe the trend in each species with figures from the data.
Explain each change as natural selection with the other species as the pressure.
Conclude: reciprocal change between interacting species is coevolution.
Watch out for
Explaining only one side. Coevolution needs both species to change in response to each other.
Saying the virus "chose" to become less lethal to keep its host alive.