Lesson 6: Isolation, gene flow and speciation
Classify three cases of speciation
SkillIsolation and speciation
Worked example
For each case, identify the type of isolation and the type of speciation, and explain how gene flow was reduced.
(a) A river changes course and splits the range of a flightless beetle. After 100 000 years, beetles from the two sides no longer mate when brought together. (b) Two populations of a frog live in the same swamp. One population breeds in early spring and the other in late summer. Over time they become separate species. (c) A grass grows across the boundary between salty coastal soil and ordinary soil. Salt-tolerant plants on the coast and non-tolerant plants inland become separate species, with a narrow zone of hybrids between them.
Step 1: Case (a)
The river is a physical barrier: geographic isolation. Beetles cannot cross, so gene flow stops completely. The two populations diverged separately until they became reproductively isolated: allopatric speciation.
Step 2: Case (b)
Breeding at different times in the same swamp is temporal isolation. Frogs from the two groups are never ready to breed at the same time, so gene flow stops even though there is no barrier: sympatric speciation.
Step 3: Case (c)
The populations are next to each other along an environmental gradient, with no barrier. Plants mate mostly with near neighbours (spatial isolation) and selection against hybrids in each soil keeps gene flow low across the contact zone: parapatric speciation.
Answer
(a) Geographic isolation, allopatric speciation. (b) Temporal isolation, sympatric speciation. (c) Spatial isolation along a gradient with a hybrid zone, parapatric speciation.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Barrier between them: geographic, allopatric.
Same area, cut by breeding time, habitat or polyploidy: sympatric.
Neighbouring populations along a gradient, contact zone: parapatric.
Always say how gene flow is reduced.
Watch out for
Calling (b) allopatric because the frogs are "separated". They are separated in time, not space.
Stopping at "isolation" without saying reproductive isolation evolved.