Lesson 3: Natural selection and the three types of selection
Identify the type of selection from a graph
SkillNatural selection and its types
Worked example
Medium ground finches on a Galápagos island eat seeds. During a severe drought, small soft seeds ran out and only large, hard seeds remained. The graph shows the beak depth of the population before the drought and of the next generation (illustrative values). Identify and justify the type of selection.
Step 1: Describe the change
The curve keeps the same shape and spread, but its peak (the mean) moves from about 9.4 mm to about 9.9 mm.
Step 2: Match the pattern
A shift of the mean towards one extreme, with no narrowing or splitting, is directional selection.
Step 3: Link to the selection pressure
Only large, hard seeds were available. Birds with deeper beaks could crack them, survived and reproduced; birds with shallow beaks starved. Beak depth is heritable, so the next generation had deeper beaks on average.
Answer
Directional selection: the mean beak depth shifted from about 9.4 to 9.9 mm because the drought favoured deep beaks that could crack the remaining hard seeds.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Beak depth before the drought (dashed) and in the next generation (solid).
Method
Same mean, narrower: stabilising. Mean shifted: directional. Two peaks or wider with the middle lost: disruptive.
Link the favoured phenotype to the selection pressure in the context.
Watch out for
Saying individual birds grew deeper beaks during the drought. The change is between generations.