Lesson 7: Genetic diversity and the risk of extinction
Why devil facial tumour disease threatens Tasmanian devils
SkillGenetic diversity and extinction
Worked example
Tasmanian devils have very low genetic diversity, especially in their MHC genes, which code for the markers the immune system uses to recognise foreign cells. Devil facial tumour disease (DFTD) is a cancer passed between devils as living tumour cells when they bite.
(a) Explain why low genetic diversity has made devils especially vulnerable to DFTD. (b) Explain why low genetic diversity increases the long-term risk of extinction of the species. (c) Evaluate the strategy of keeping disease-free insurance populations in captivity. (6 marks)
Step 1: (a) Link MHC diversity to the disease
Because devils' MHC markers are so similar, tumour cells from one devil do not look foreign to another devil's immune system, so they are not rejected and grow. In a diverse species the transplanted cells would usually be destroyed.
Step 2: (a) Shared susceptibility
With little variation, almost no devils carry alleles that give resistance, so the disease can affect nearly the whole population.
Step 3: (b) Ability to adapt
Natural selection needs heritable variation. With few alleles, the population has little capacity to adapt to DFTD or to future changes such as new diseases or climate change.
Step 4: (b) Inbreeding and decline
As numbers fall, inbreeding increases homozygosity, harmful recessive alleles are expressed and survival and breeding fall, making the population smaller still.
Step 5: (c) Evaluate insurance populations
Strengths: they protect devils from DFTD and keep a source of animals to release. Limitations: captive populations are small, so drift and inbreeding can reduce diversity further unless breeding is managed to keep as many alleles as possible; captive-bred animals may cope less well in the wild; they do not stop the disease in wild devils. Judgement: a worthwhile safety net, but only effective combined with managed breeding for diversity and work on the wild population.
Answer
(a) Similar MHC markers mean tumour cells are not recognised as foreign and are not rejected, and few devils have resistance alleles. (b) Little variation for selection to act on, and inbreeding depression, make decline and extinction more likely. (c) A valuable safety net if breeding is managed to keep diversity, but limited by small size, possible adaptation to captivity, and no effect on the disease in the wild.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Link the specific gene (MHC) to the specific threat.
General risks: reduced ability to adapt, shared susceptibility, inbreeding depression.
Evaluate: strengths, limitations, then a judgement.
Watch out for
Saying the devils "cannot evolve resistance" at all. Selection is acting on the variation that remains.