Lesson 7: Niches and competitive exclusion
Lichens on a tree trunk and competitive exclusion
SkillsNiches and competitive exclusionSpecies interactions
Worked example
Students investigated vertical zonation on the trunks of ten paperbark trees (Melaleuca quinquenervia) beside a lagoon. On each trunk they placed a quadrat at the centre of each height band on the side facing the water, and recorded the percentage cover of two crustose lichen species.
| Height band (m) | – | – | – | – |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lichen P, mean cover (%) | ||||
| Lichen Q, mean cover (%) |
(a) Describe the distribution of the two lichens. (b) The students concluded that competition between P and Q causes the zonation. Evaluate this conclusion. (c) Propose a modification to the investigation that would test it.
Step 1: Describe the pattern with data
Lichen P is most abundant at the base ( at –) and decreases with height to at –. Lichen Q shows the opposite: at the base, rising to at the top. The two trends cross between the – and – bands, where both species are common.
Step 2: What supports the conclusion
The two species largely replace each other along the trunk (a negative relationship), which is what competitive exclusion would produce: each may be the better competitor in its own zone, giving each a realised niche narrower than its fundamental niche.
Step 3: What weakens the conclusion
The data are correlational. Abiotic factors change with height on a trunk beside water: humidity, splash, shade and bark texture. P may simply need the wetter base and Q the drier, brighter upper trunk, with no competition at all. The survey also used only one side of each trunk and one season.
"Evaluate" needs both sides and a judgement.
Step 4: Judgement
The conclusion is plausible but not supported by these data alone: they show zonation, not its cause.
Step 5: Modify the investigation
Run a removal experiment: on each tree, scrape lichen P from marked squares in its zone and leave matched squares untouched as controls; do the same for Q in its zone. Record the cover of the other species in each square every few months for a year. At the same time, measure light intensity and humidity in each height band with data loggers. If Q spreads into cleared squares in P's zone (and vice versa), competition is excluding it; if not, abiotic factors are the likelier cause.
Answer
(a) P decreases with height (52 % → 2 %), Q increases (3 % → 47 %). (b) Consistent with competitive exclusion, but correlational: an abiotic gradient (moisture, light) could explain it, so the conclusion is not yet justified. (c) A replicated removal experiment with controls, plus abiotic measurements in each band.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe each species' trend with numbers from the data.
Separate pattern (correlation) from cause (competition or abiotic factors).
Test competition by removing one species and watching the other, with controls and replicates.
Watch out for
Treating zonation as proof of competition.
Suggesting "more trees" as the only improvement when the problem is the type of evidence.