Lesson 6: Species interactions
Classify interactions from growth data
SkillSpecies interactions
Worked example
Three pairs of species were each studied alone and together. The table gives a measure of each species' success (population size or growth) under each condition.
| Pair | Species A alone | Species A together | Species B alone | Species B together |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1: two grass species in pots | ||||
| 2: a black ant and a sap-sucking bug on a wattle | ||||
| 3: an orchid and the tree it grows on |
For pair 3, the orchid is A (its success is its biomass, in g, which is zero alone because it cannot establish on the ground) and the tree is B (its growth in cm per year).
Name the interaction in each pair and justify each with the data.
Step 1: Pair 1
A falls from alone to together; B falls from to . Both are harmed (−/−): competition, probably for light, water and soil nutrients.
Step 2: Pair 2
The ants increase from to and the bugs from to . Both benefit (+/+): mutualism. (Ants commonly protect sap-sucking bugs from predators and feed on the sugary honeydew they excrete.)
Step 3: Pair 3
The orchid grows only on the tree ( → , +), and the tree's growth is the same either way (, 0). One benefits, the other is unaffected (+/0): commensalism.
Step 4: Comment on the evidence
The conclusions rest on single values. Replicates (several pots or trees per treatment) and a statistical comparison would show whether differences such as and are really equal, or whether small effects are being missed.
Answer
Pair 1 competition (both lower together); pair 2 mutualism (both higher together); pair 3 commensalism (the orchid benefits, the tree's growth is unchanged).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare each species together with alone: higher (+), lower (−) or the same (0).
Combine the two signs: +/+ mutualism, −/− competition, +/− predation or parasitism, +/0 commensalism.
Quote the numbers for both species.
Watch out for
Comparing species A with species B instead of each species with itself alone.
Naming the interaction without giving the effect on each species.