Lesson 8: Keystone species and predicting removals
Is this sea star a keystone species?
SkillsKeystone species and removalsSpecies interactions
Worked example
On a rocky shore, ecologists removed a predatory sea star by hand from five plots each year, and left five similar plots as controls. The sea star made up less than of the animal biomass on the shore.
| Year | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean species richness, control plots | ||||
| Mean species richness, removal plots | ||||
| Mean mussel cover, removal plots (%) |
(a) Calculate the percentage change in species richness in the removal plots from year 0 to year 3. (b) Use the data to justify that the sea star is a keystone species. (c) Explain the mechanism that links the removal to the loss of species. (d) State one limitation of the conclusion.
Step 1: Percentage change
Step 2: Compare with the controls
Richness in the control plots stayed at – species, so the fall to in the removal plots is due to the removal, not to weather or season.
Step 3: Effect out of proportion to abundance
The sea star is under of the animal biomass, yet removing it halved species richness in three years. A large effect on community structure relative to its abundance is the definition of a keystone species.
Step 4: Mechanism
The sea star preys on mussels, the dominant competitor for space on the rock. Without it, mussel cover rose from to . The mussels outcompeted and smothered other space-holding species (barnacles, algae, limpets), which were excluded: predation on the dominant competitor had been preventing competitive exclusion.
Step 5: Limitation
The study covers one shore and three years; the effect may differ on sheltered shores, or the community may change further. Mussel beds also provide habitat for small animals that may not have been counted in species richness.
Answer
(a) . (b) Removal halved richness while controls stayed at 14–15, though the sea star is under 3 % of biomass. (c) It eats the dominant competitor (mussels); without it mussels covered 80 % of the rock and excluded other species. (d) One site and three years; small mussel-bed animals may not be counted.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Percentage change = (new − original) ÷ original × 100.
Compare treatment with control to attribute the change to the removal.
Keystone = large effect relative to abundance; explain the mechanism through the food web.
Watch out for
Forgetting the minus sign for a decrease.
Not using the control plots as evidence.