Lesson 7 of 10 · 15 min
Xylem and phloem
Compare the structure and function of xylem and phloem, what each carries, which way and how, and find them in roots, stems and leaves.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the cells that make up xylem and phloem and how their structure suits their function.
- Explain how water moves up the xylem and how sugars are translocated in the phloem from source to sink.
- Compare xylem and phloem by structure, contents, direction of flow and energy use.
- Interpret evidence from experiments on plant transport.
Mountain ash (Eucalyptus regnans) is the tallest flowering plant on Earth; the tallest one known, Centurion in Tasmania, is about 100 m high. Every day it lifts hundreds of litres of water from its roots to leaves the height of a 30-storey building, and sends sugar from those leaves back down to the roots, all without a heart or a single pump. It does this with two tissues, xylem and phloem.
Definition
Vascular tissue
Xylem carries water and dissolved mineral ions from the roots up to the stems and leaves.
Phloem carries sugars (mainly sucrose) and other organic substances, such as amino acids and hormones, from where they are made or stored to where they are used. This is translocation.
The two run side by side in vascular bundles, through the roots, stems and leaf veins.
Xylem is built mostly from vessel elements: long cells that die when mature, leaving their walls behind. Their end walls break down, so they join end to end into continuous hollow tubes, vessels, with no cytoplasm in the way. The walls are thickened with lignin, laid down in rings, spirals or networks, which makes them strong enough not to collapse under the tension inside, waterproof, and stiff enough to help hold the plant up. Small unthickened areas, pits, let water pass sideways between vessels.
Left: a xylem vessel, dead and hollow, strengthened by lignin. Right: a living phloem sieve tube element with sieve plates, and its companion cell.
How water rises. Water evaporates from the cells inside the leaf and diffuses out through the stomata (transpiration, the next lesson). That loss pulls more water out of the xylem in the leaf veins. Water molecules stick to each other (cohesion) and to the vessel walls (adhesion), so the whole column of water is pulled up the stem as one continuous thread, the transpiration stream. This cohesion–tension mechanism is passive: the energy comes from the Sun evaporating water, not from ATP. Water and ions move only upwards in the xylem.
Phloem is built from sieve tube elements joined end to end. They are living, but at maturity they lose their nucleus and most organelles, leaving a thin layer of cytoplasm so sap can flow through. Their end walls are sieve plates, perforated with pores. Each sieve tube element has a companion cell beside it, with a nucleus, dense cytoplasm and many mitochondria, joined to it by plasmodesmata. The companion cell keeps the sieve tube alive and uses ATP to load sugar into it.
How sugar moves. A source is any part that makes or releases sugar, such as a photosynthesising leaf or a tuber in spring. A sink is any part that uses or stores it, such as roots, growing tips, flowers and fruit. At the source, companion cells actively load sucrose into the sieve tubes. Water follows by osmosis from the nearby xylem, raising the pressure. At the sink, sucrose is unloaded and water leaves, lowering the pressure. Sap flows from high to low pressure, from source to sink, which can be up or down the plant. (This is the pressure-flow, or mass-flow, model.)
Pick a source and a sink and watch which way the phloem sap flows. Then sort the features.
| Feature | Xylem | Phloem |
|---|---|---|
| Main cells | Vessel elements (and tracheids) | Sieve tube elements and companion cells |
| Living or dead | Dead at maturity, hollow | Living (sieve tubes have no nucleus; companion cells do) |
| Cell walls | Thickened with lignin | Cellulose, no lignin |
| End walls | Broken down: a continuous tube | Sieve plates with pores |
| Carries | Water and mineral ions | Sucrose, amino acids, hormones |
| Direction | Up only, roots to leaves | Source to sink, up or down |
| Driven by | Transpiration pull (cohesion–tension), passive | Pressure differences set up by active loading, needs ATP |
| Other role | Support (lignified walls) | No support role for sieve tubes (phloem fibres help in some plants) |
Name the substance that thickens and waterproofs the walls of xylem vessels.
In spring, a potato tuber in the soil supplies sugar to the new shoots growing above it. Which statement is correct?
Worked example
Compare xylem and phloem
Compare the structure and function of xylem and phloem tissue.
Step 1: Similarities first
Both are vascular tissues made of long cells joined end to end into tubes, found together in vascular bundles in roots, stems and leaves.
Step 2: Structure
Xylem vessels are dead and hollow, with lignified walls and no end walls; whereas phloem sieve tubes are living, with cellulose walls, sieve plates and a companion cell beside each element.
Step 3: What they carry
Xylem carries water and mineral ions, whereas phloem carries sugars (mainly sucrose), amino acids and hormones.
Step 4: Direction and mechanism
Xylem carries its contents up from the roots, pulled passively by transpiration (cohesion–tension); phloem carries sap from source to sink, up or down, driven by active loading of sugar that uses ATP.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both are tubes of cells in vascular bundles. Xylem: dead, hollow, lignified vessels carrying water and minerals up, passively. Phloem: living sieve tubes with sieve plates and companion cells carrying sugars from source to sink in either direction, using ATP.
Method
Give at least one similarity.
Pair each difference with "whereas".
Cover structure, contents, direction and energy.
Watch out for
Describing xylem in one paragraph and phloem in another with no comparison words.
Saying phloem only carries sugar downwards.
Where they are. In a young stem of a flowering plant like a sunflower, the vascular bundles form a ring near the outside, with xylem towards the centre and phloem towards the outside. In a root they are in the centre, with xylem in a star or cross shape and phloem between its arms. In a leaf vein the xylem is on the upper side and the phloem below.
Note
Evidence for how transport works
- Dyes: a celery stalk stood in coloured water shows the dye only in the xylem.
- Aphids: an aphid's mouthparts (stylet) tap a single sieve tube; cut from the aphid, the stylet keeps oozing sap rich in sucrose, under pressure.
- Ringing: removing a ring of bark, which contains the phloem, makes the stem swell just above the ring as sugars build up, while the leaves stay supplied with water by the xylem in the wood.
Worked example
What a ring of bark reveals about phloem
A complete ring of bark (which contains the phloem) was removed from the trunk of a young tree, leaving the wood (xylem) intact. After three weeks the bark just above the ring had swollen, and the sucrose concentration in the bark was measured.
| Position | Sucrose concentration in bark (% by mass) |
|---|---|
| 5 cm above the ring | 4.2 |
| 5 cm below the ring | 0.9 |
The leaves stayed green and turgid throughout. (a) Explain the difference in sucrose concentration. (b) Explain why the leaves did not wilt. (c) Predict what would eventually happen to the roots, with a reason.
Step 1: Identify the source and the sink
The leaves are the source of sucrose; the roots below the ring are a sink.
Step 2: Explain the build-up above the ring
Sucrose translocated down the phloem from the leaves cannot pass the gap, so it accumulates above the ring (4.2 %), and the bark swells as water follows by osmosis. Below the ring little sucrose arrives (0.9 %).
Step 3: Explain why the leaves stay turgid
The xylem, in the wood, was left intact, so water and minerals still travel up from the roots to the leaves in the transpiration stream.
Step 4: Predict the effect on the roots
The roots receive no sucrose, so once their stored starch is used up they cannot respire to make ATP. They die, and the tree dies with them (this is called ringbarking).
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Phloem carries sucrose down from the leaves; the ring blocks it, so sucrose builds up above. (b) The xylem is intact, so water still reaches the leaves. (c) The roots run out of sugar for respiration and die, killing the tree.
Method
Decide which tissue was removed and which was left.
Use source and sink to predict where sugar builds up.
Watch out for
Saying the leaves wilt because the bark is removed. Water travels in the xylem, which is intact.
Common mistake
Phloem is not "one way down"
Students often learn "xylem up, phloem down". Xylem does go only up, but phloem goes from source to sink: down to the roots, but also up to young leaves, flowers and fruit. Phloem in one stem can carry sap upward and downward at the same time, in different sieve tubes.
Exam tip
Comparing tissues
A "compare" answer needs paired points: "Xylem vessels are dead and hollow, whereas phloem sieve tubes are living." Cover structure (cells, lignin, end walls), contents, direction and whether energy is used. A similarity counts too: both are long tubes of cells joined end to end in vascular bundles.
Summary
Xylem: dead, hollow, lignified vessels; carries water and mineral ions up from the roots; driven passively by transpiration pull (cohesion–tension); also supports the plant.
Phloem: living sieve tube elements with sieve plates, and companion cells; translocates sucrose and amino acids from source to sink, up or down; needs ATP to load sugar.
A source makes or releases sugar (leaves, a tuber in spring); a sink uses or stores it (roots, fruit, growing tips).
In a stem the xylem is on the inside of each vascular bundle and the phloem on the outside.
Dyes, aphid stylets and ringing experiments show what each tissue carries.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.