Lesson 10 of 10 · 12 min
Technology inspired by natural systems
See how scientists copy photosynthesis and gas exchange surfaces to build artificial leaves that make fuel, lung-on-a-chip devices and artificial lungs, and evaluate how they compare with the real thing.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how an artificial leaf copies the light-dependent and light-independent reactions of photosynthesis.
- Describe how lung-on-a-chip devices and membrane oxygenators copy the structure of the alveoli and capillaries.
- Evaluate a nature-inspired technology against the natural system it copies.
Photosynthetic organisms have been turning sunlight, water and carbon dioxide into fuel for more than two billion years, and lungs have been exchanging gases across a barrier about a two-hundredth the thickness of a sheet of paper for hundreds of millions. When engineers want to make fuel from sunlight, or move oxygen into blood, they increasingly start by asking how living things already do it. Designing technology by copying living structures and processes is called biomimicry.
Key idea
How scientists use natural systems
- Understand the natural system: its structure, the steps of the process and what limits it.
- Identify the principle that makes it work: a catalyst that splits water, a huge thin surface for diffusion.
- Rebuild the principle with human-made materials, often improving on one weakness of the original.
- Test and compare the new technology with the natural one: efficiency, cost, lifetime, side effects.
The artificial leaf. Photosynthesis has two jobs: capture light energy and split water (the light-dependent reactions), then use that energy to reduce carbon dioxide to a fuel, glucose (the light-independent reactions). An artificial leaf does the same two jobs with different parts. A light absorber, a semiconductor such as silicon or a perovskite, plays the part of chlorophyll. A catalyst on one side splits water and releases oxygen, as photolysis does. On the other side a second catalyst, or living bacteria, uses the electrons and hydrogen to turn carbon dioxide into a fuel.
An artificial leaf does the two jobs of photosynthesis with human-made parts: capture light and split water (like the light-dependent reactions), then reduce carbon dioxide to a fuel (like the light-independent reactions).
| Year | Group | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Daniel Nocera and colleagues, MIT (Reece et al., Science) | A silicon wafer coated with cheap cobalt- and nickel-based catalysts, dropped in water in sunlight, released oxygen from one face and hydrogen from the other: water splitting without wires. |
| 2016 | Nocera and Pamela Silver, Harvard (Liu et al., Science) | The "bionic leaf": hydrogen from water splitting fed to the bacterium Cupriavidus necator (Ralstonia eutropha), which used it to fix carbon dioxide into biomass and liquid fuels such as isopropanol, storing about 10 % of the solar energy, several times what most crops achieve. |
| 2023 | Erwin Reisner and colleagues, University of Cambridge (Rahaman et al., Nature Energy) | A standalone artificial leaf with a copper–palladium catalyst that turned carbon dioxide and water into ethanol and propanol, liquid fuels, using only sunlight. |
Natural leaf
- Chlorophyll absorbs mainly red and blue light.
- Stores roughly 1–2 % of the sunlight falling on a crop as chemical energy over a season.
- Makes glucose, which must be harvested and processed to become a fuel.
- Builds and repairs itself, using cheap, abundant elements.
Artificial leaf
- Semiconductors can absorb a wider range of wavelengths.
- Some designs store a larger share of the light energy (around 10 % in the bionic leaf).
- Can make a liquid fuel (ethanol, propanol, isopropanol) or hydrogen directly.
- Catalysts and absorbers degrade over time; many designs still use rare or costly materials and work only at small scale.
In an artificial leaf, a catalyst on one face splits water and releases oxygen. Which stage of photosynthesis does this copy?
Worked example
Could artificial leaves replace crops as a fuel source?
A site receives of sunlight per square metre per day. A biofuel crop stores about 1 % of the sunlight falling on it as chemical energy; a "bionic leaf" device has been reported to store about 10 %.
(a) Calculate the energy stored per square metre per day by each. (b) Calculate the area of crop needed to store as much energy as of bionic leaf. (c) Evaluate the claim that artificial leaves will soon replace crops as a source of fuel.
Step 1: Energy stored by the crop
per day
Step 2: Energy stored by the bionic leaf
per day
Step 3: Equivalent crop area
of crop for each of bionic leaf.
Step 4: Strengths
The device stores about ten times as much of the sunlight per square metre, can make a liquid fuel directly, and does not need farmland, fertiliser or a growing season.
Step 5: Limitations and judgement
It has been demonstrated only at laboratory scale; catalysts and absorbers degrade, some use costly materials, and the device must be built and maintained, while a crop builds and repairs itself from cheap, abundant elements. Judgement: artificial leaves are a promising complement to biofuel crops, but the claim that they will soon replace crops is not yet supported.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Crop 0.20 MJ m⁻² per day; bionic leaf 2.0 MJ m⁻² per day. (b) 10 m². (c) More efficient per area and makes fuel directly, but only proven at small scale, with durability and cost problems: not yet a replacement.
Method
Energy stored = efficiency × energy received.
Evaluate: strengths, limitations against criteria, then a justified judgement.
Watch out for
Giving only strengths or only limitations in an evaluation.
Writing 10 % as 10 instead of 0.10 in the calculation.
Lung-on-a-chip. In 2010 Dongeun Huh, Donald Ingber and colleagues at Harvard's Wyss Institute built a device the size of a memory stick that copies the alveolar–capillary barrier (Huh et al., Science, 2010). A thin, porous, flexible membrane carries human alveolar epithelial cells on one side, facing a channel of air, and capillary endothelial cells on the other, facing a channel of flowing fluid. Vacuum channels on either side stretch the membrane rhythmically, as breathing stretches the alveoli. Researchers use such chips to study lung disease and to test drugs and toxic particles on human cells, which can reduce and refine the use of animals in research.
Artificial lungs. A membrane oxygenator, used in heart surgery and in ECMO (extracorporeal membrane oxygenation) for patients whose lungs have failed, copies the alveoli directly. Blood is pumped past thousands of hollow fibres whose thin, gas-permeable walls give a total area of about , with oxygen flowing through them. Oxygen diffuses into the blood and carbon dioxide out, down their partial pressure gradients. The same rules apply as in the lung: large area, thin barrier, steep gradients kept up by flow on both sides.
An engineer designs a membrane oxygenator in which blood and oxygen flow in opposite directions past the fibre walls. Which feature of a natural exchange surface does this copy, and why does it help?
Exam tip
Evaluating a technology
For "evaluate" in science as a human endeavour, weigh strengths and limitations against criteria, then give a judgement. For an artificial leaf: efficiency compared with plants, the fuel it makes, the cost and abundance of its materials, how long it lasts, whether it can be scaled up, and whether its carbon dioxide comes from the air (closing the carbon cycle) or from fossil sources.
Summary
Biomimicry: understanding how a natural system works and rebuilding its principle with human-made materials.
Artificial leaves copy photosynthesis: a light absorber and catalyst split water (like the light-dependent reactions), and a second catalyst or bacteria turn carbon dioxide into fuel (like the light-independent reactions).
Milestones: wireless water splitting (Nocera, 2011), the bionic leaf storing about 10 % of solar energy (2016), liquid fuels from an artificial leaf (Cambridge, 2023).
Lung-on-a-chip devices and membrane oxygenators copy the alveolar–capillary barrier: a large, thin surface with steep gradients maintained by flow.
Evaluate a technology against criteria such as efficiency, cost, lifetime, scale and environmental impact.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.