Lesson 3 of 10 · 15 min

Aerobic and anaerobic respiration

Compare aerobic respiration with lactic acid fermentation in muscle and alcoholic fermentation in yeast and plants, by oxygen, location, products and ATP yield.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why glycolysis can continue without oxygen only if NAD⁺ is regenerated by fermentation.
  • Describe lactic acid fermentation in animals and alcoholic fermentation in yeast and plants, with their equations.
  • Compare aerobic and anaerobic respiration by oxygen use, location, products and ATP per glucose.
  • Interpret data from a fermentation experiment.

Sprint flat out for 30 seconds and your legs burn, your breathing races and it keeps racing for minutes after you stop. Bake bread and the dough rises as yeast fills it with bubbles of gas. Both are the same story: cells releasing energy from glucose when there is not enough oxygen for aerobic respiration.

What happens when oxygen runs short. Oxygen is the final electron acceptor of the electron transport chain. Without it the chain stops, NADH can no longer hand over its electrons, and the Krebs cycle stops too, for want of NAD+\text{NAD}^+.

Glycolysis does not need oxygen, but it does need NAD+\text{NAD}^+. A cell that keeps making NADH and cannot get rid of its electrons soon runs out of NAD+\text{NAD}^+, and glycolysis stops. Fermentation solves this: the cell passes the electrons from NADH to pyruvate, regenerating NAD+\text{NAD}^+ so glycolysis can keep making its 2 ATP per glucose. Glycolysis followed by fermentation is anaerobic respiration.

Definition

Two kinds of anaerobic respiration

Lactic acid fermentation (animals, including human muscle; some bacteria): pyruvate is converted to lactic acid (lactate). No carbon dioxide is made.

CX6HX12OX6→2 CX3HX6OX3+2 ATP\ce{C6H12O6 -> 2C3H6O3} + \text{2 ATP}

Alcoholic fermentation (yeast; plant cells such as roots in waterlogged soil): pyruvate is converted to ethanol and carbon dioxide.

CX6HX12OX6→2 CX2HX5OH+2 COX2+2 ATP\ce{C6H12O6 -> 2C2H5OH + 2CO2} + \text{2 ATP}

Both happen entirely in the cytosol and yield only the 2 ATP from glycolysis per glucose.

Interactive

Turn down the oxygen

Drag the oxygen slider and switch between animal and yeast. Compare the products and the ATP per glucose.

Name the product of anaerobic respiration in human muscle cells.

Comparing aerobic and anaerobic respiration
FeatureAerobic respirationAnaerobic: lactic acid fermentationAnaerobic: alcoholic fermentation
OxygenNeeded (final electron acceptor)Not neededNot needed
WhereCytosol, then mitochondrionCytosol onlyCytosol only
StagesGlycolysis, Krebs cycle, electron transport chainGlycolysis, then pyruvate → lactateGlycolysis, then pyruvate → ethanol + CO₂
ProductsCO₂, H₂OLactic acidEthanol, CO₂
ATP per glucose36–3822
Glucose broken downCompletelyPartly (energy left in lactate)Partly (energy left in ethanol)
OrganismsMost eukaryotes and many prokaryotesAnimals, some bacteriaYeast, plants

Key idea

Similarities matter too

"Compare" means similarities as well as differences. Both kinds of respiration begin with glycolysis in the cytosol, both break down glucose to release energy, and both make ATP from ADP and Pi\text{P}_\text{i}. They differ in whether oxygen is used, where the later steps happen, the products, and how much ATP each glucose yields.

A cell needs 36 ATP. How many glucose molecules must it respire anaerobically to make them, compared with one glucose molecule respired aerobically for 36 ATP?

Why bother with anaerobic respiration? It is wasteful, but it is fast. Glycolysis can make ATP much faster than the mitochondria can, so during a sprint your fast-twitch muscle fibres rely on it for the burst. Yeast in a sealed bread dough or a wine vat, and the roots of a plant in waterlogged soil, have no choice: there is no oxygen.

After exercise. Lactate passes into the blood and is carried to the liver, where it is converted back to pyruvate and glucose. That takes energy, so it takes oxygen. The extra oxygen you take in after exercise, to deal with lactate and to restore ATP, creatine phosphate and the oxygen stored in myoglobin, is the oxygen debt (excess post-exercise oxygen consumption). It is why you keep breathing hard after you stop.

Common mistake

Lactic acid and sore muscles

The soreness you feel a day or two after hard exercise is not lactic acid: lactate is cleared from the blood within about an hour. Delayed soreness comes from small injuries to muscle fibres. During exercise, though, the build-up of lactate and hydrogen ions is one of several changes linked to fatigue.

Common mistake

Plants are not always aerobic

Plant cells respire aerobically when they have oxygen, like animal cells, but roots in flooded soil switch to alcoholic fermentation. Ethanol is toxic, which is one reason most plants die if their roots stay waterlogged.

Worked example

Temperature and the rate of fermentation in yeast

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

A student mixed 1.0 g1.0\unit{g} of dried yeast with 50 mL50\unit{mL} of 5 % glucose solution in a flask, kept air out by covering the mixture with a layer of oil, and connected the flask to a gas syringe. Each flask was kept in a water bath for 10 minutes. The mean volume of gas collected (three trials) is shown.

Temperature (°C)1525354555
Mean volume of gas in 10 min (cm3\mathrm{cm^3})4.29.618.412.11.5

(a) Name the gas and write the equation for the process. (b) Calculate the rate of gas production at 35 °C35\unit{°C}. (c) Describe and explain the trend. (d) Suggest one improvement to find the optimum temperature more precisely.

6 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Identify the process from the conditions (no air → fermentation → CO₂).

  2. Rate = amount ÷ time, with units.

  3. Describe the trend with numbers, then explain it with enzyme activity and denaturation.

Watch out for

  • Saying the yeast "dies" at high temperature as the whole explanation. Name the enzymes and denaturation.

  • Quoting the optimum as exactly 35 °C. The data only show it lies between 25 and 45 °C.

Yeast is mixed with glucose solution in a sealed flask with no air. The flask is connected to a gas syringe. Which observation shows that the yeast is respiring?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Glucose needed for a sprint, aerobically and anaerobically

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

During a race a runner's leg muscles use 0.72 mol0.72\unit{mol} of ATP. Assume aerobic respiration yields 36 ATP and anaerobic respiration 2 ATP per glucose.

(a) Calculate the amount of glucose needed if all the ATP came from aerobic respiration, and if it all came from anaerobic respiration. (b) Calculate the mass of glucose in each case (M=180 g mol−1M = 180\unit{g\,mol^{-1}}). (c) Explain why a sprinter's muscles still rely heavily on anaerobic respiration.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Glucose needed = ATP needed ÷ ATP per glucose.

  2. Mass = moles × molar mass.

  3. Efficiency per glucose and rate of ATP supply are different things.

Watch out for

  • Multiplying by the ATP per glucose instead of dividing.

  • Saying anaerobic respiration is used because it is more efficient. It is faster, not more efficient.

Exam tip

Writing a comparison

Use comparative language in every sentence ("whereas", "both", "only"), and cover at least oxygen, location, products and ATP. For example: "Both begin with glycolysis in the cytosol. Aerobic respiration requires oxygen and continues in the mitochondria, producing carbon dioxide, water and 36–38 ATP per glucose, whereas anaerobic respiration in muscle requires no oxygen, occurs only in the cytosol and produces lactic acid and 2 ATP."

Summary

  • Without oxygen the electron transport chain and Krebs cycle stop. Fermentation regenerates NAD⁺ so glycolysis can continue.

  • Lactic acid fermentation (animals): CX6HX12OX6→2 CX3HX6OX3\ce{C6H12O6 -> 2C3H6O3} + 2 ATP. Alcoholic fermentation (yeast, plants): CX6HX12OX6→2 CX2HX5OH+2 COX2\ce{C6H12O6 -> 2C2H5OH + 2CO2} + 2 ATP.

  • Anaerobic respiration is in the cytosol only and yields 2 ATP per glucose; aerobic yields 36–38, about 18–19 times as much.

  • Anaerobic respiration is fast, which suits short bursts of intense exercise, but wasteful: much energy is left in lactate or ethanol.

  • The oxygen debt after exercise is the extra oxygen used to clear lactate and restore ATP and oxygen stores.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 3 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account