Lesson 4: Projections, work and relative velocity
Do two drones come too close?
SkillsModelling with vectorsScalar and vector projections
Worked example
Two drones fly in straight lines at constant velocity. Take east, north and up, with distances in metres. At seconds drone is at with velocity , and drone is at with velocity .
Safety rules require the drones to stay at least 10 m apart. Determine whether the rule is broken, and if so, when the drones are closest.
Step 1: Find the relative position and velocity
At the position of relative to is . The velocity of relative to is .
Working relative to turns two moving objects into one: moving past a fixed .
Step 2: Write the separation at time
.
Step 3: Square its length
Minimising the squared distance avoids square roots, and the minimum happens at the same .
Step 4: Find the minimum of the quadratic
The turning point is at s, where .
Step 5: Find the closest distance
m.
Step 6: Interpret
The drones come within about 9.9 m of each other, about 10.2 s after the start, so the 10 m rule is broken, though only just.
Reasonableness: they start m apart and close at about , so meeting the closest point after about 10 s is sensible.
Answer
Yes. The drones are closest about 10.2 s after the start, when they are about 9.88 m apart, less than the required 10 m.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Work relative to one object: subtract positions and subtract velocities.
Write the separation as a function of and minimise its square.
Equivalently, the closest approach is the length of the part of the initial separation perpendicular to the relative velocity.
Answer the question that was asked, with units.
Watch out for
Finding the closest distance between the two flight paths instead. The paths can come closer than the drones do, because the drones pass those points at different times.
Subtracting velocities in one order and positions in the other.