Lesson 4 of 8 · 14 min

Do the particles meet, or do their paths only cross?

Compare the positions of two particles given as vector functions of time, and decide whether they collide or their paths merely cross.

What you will be able to do

  • Test whether two particles meet by solving rA(t)=rB(t)\mathbf{r}_A(t) = \mathbf{r}_B(t) with one time variable.
  • Test whether two paths cross by solving rA(t1)=rB(t2)\mathbf{r}_A(t_1) = \mathbf{r}_B(t_2) with two time variables.
  • Justify a conclusion by checking every component.

Two planes fly over Rockhampton on straight paths that cross on the map. Is that a near miss or a disaster? It depends on when each plane reaches the crossing point. Paths that cross are common and harmless; particles that are at the same place at the same time collide.

The particles meet (collide)

Same position, same time. Solve

rA(t)=rB(t)\mathbf{r}_A(t) = \mathbf{r}_B(t)

with one variable tt. Each component gives an equation; one value of tt must satisfy all of them.

The paths cross

Same position, possibly different times. Solve

rA(t1)=rB(t2)\mathbf{r}_A(t_1) = \mathbf{r}_B(t_2)

with two variables. Use two components to find t1t_1 and t2t_2, then check the rest.

Take particle AA with rA(t)=2t i^+(t+1) j^\mathbf{r}_A(t) = 2t\,\hat{\mathbf{i}} + (t + 1)\,\hat{\mathbf{j}} and particle BB with rB(t)=(t+3) i^+3t j^\mathbf{r}_B(t) = (t + 3)\,\hat{\mathbf{i}} + 3t\,\hat{\mathbf{j}}, for t≥0t \ge 0.

Do they meet? Equate the i^\hat{\mathbf{i}}-components at the same time: 2t=t+32t = t + 3, so t=3t = 3. At t=3t = 3 the j^\hat{\mathbf{j}}-components are AA: 3+1=43 + 1 = 4 and BB: 99. They disagree, so the particles never meet.

Do the paths cross? Use separate times: 2t1=t2+32t_1 = t_2 + 3 and t1+1=3t2t_1 + 1 = 3t_2. Substituting t1=3t2−1t_1 = 3t_2 - 1 into the first, 6t2−2=t2+36t_2 - 2 = t_2 + 3, so t2=1t_2 = 1 and t1=2t_1 = 2. Both paths pass through rA(2)=rB(1)=4i^+3j^\mathbf{r}_A(2) = \mathbf{r}_B(1) = 4\hat{\mathbf{i}} + 3\hat{\mathbf{j}}, but BB is there at t=1t = 1 and AA arrives a second later.

The paths cross at (4,3)(4, 3), but BB is there at t=1t = 1 and AA at t=2t = 2. The particles do not collide.

Two particles have position vectors rA(t)\mathbf{r}_A(t) and rB(t)\mathbf{r}_B(t). You find that rA(2)=rB(5)\mathbf{r}_A(2) = \mathbf{r}_B(5). What can you conclude?

Choose one answer

Testing for a collision

  1. Equate one pair of components with the same tt

    Choose the simplest, often a linear one, and solve for tt.

  2. Keep only allowed times

    Discard any tt outside the given interval, such as t<0t < 0.

  3. Check every other component at that tt

    If all agree, the particles meet. Find the meeting point by substituting into either r(t)\mathbf{r}(t).

  4. State the conclusion with a reason

    For example: "At t=3t = 3 the j^\hat{\mathbf{j}}-components are 4 and 9, so the particles do not collide."

Particles AA and BB move with rA(t)=(3t−2) i^+(t+4) j^\mathbf{r}_A(t) = (3t - 2)\,\hat{\mathbf{i}} + (t + 4)\,\hat{\mathbf{j}} and rB(t)=(t+2) i^+(2t+2) j^\mathbf{r}_B(t) = (t + 2)\,\hat{\mathbf{i}} + (2t + 2)\,\hat{\mathbf{j}} for t≥0t \ge 0. They collide. At what time?

Worked example

Paths that cross without a collision

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology free

Two drones have position vectors, in metres after tt seconds,

rA(t)=(1+t) i^+2t j^+(3−t) k^,rB(t)=(t−1) i^+(5−t) j^+2 k^.\mathbf{r}_A(t) = (1 + t)\,\hat{\mathbf{i}} + 2t\,\hat{\mathbf{j}} + (3 - t)\,\hat{\mathbf{k}}, \qquad \mathbf{r}_B(t) = (t - 1)\,\hat{\mathbf{i}} + (5 - t)\,\hat{\mathbf{j}} + 2\,\hat{\mathbf{k}}.

(a) Show that the drones never collide.

(b) Show that their paths cross, and find the point where they do.

6 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Collision: one time tt, every component equal.

  2. Crossing: times t1t_1 and t2t_2; solve two components, check the third.

  3. Substitute back to find the point, and state both times.

Watch out for

  • Using the same letter tt for both drones in part (b), which tests for a collision again.

  • Not checking the third component in three dimensions.

Common mistake

One component is not enough

Solving the i^\hat{\mathbf{i}}-components and stopping proves nothing. Two particles always have equal xx-coordinates at some moments; they collide only if every component agrees at that moment. In three dimensions there are three equations and still only one unknown tt, so collisions are rare.

Exam tip

Write the conclusion

"Show that the particles do not collide" earns its last mark for the sentence that names the component that disagrees. "Find where the paths cross" needs both times and the point, and a check of the remaining component in 3D.

Summary

  • Meet (collide): rA(t)=rB(t)\mathbf{r}_A(t) = \mathbf{r}_B(t) for one value of tt; every component must agree at that time.

  • Paths cross: rA(t1)=rB(t2)\mathbf{r}_A(t_1) = \mathbf{r}_B(t_2); solve two components for t1t_1 and t2t_2, check the others.

  • If the particles meet, the paths cross; the reverse is not true.

  • Discard times outside the domain, and justify "no" with the component that fails.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 4 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account