Lesson 4: Do the particles meet, or do their paths only cross?
Paths that cross without a collision
SkillDo the particles meet?
Worked example
Two drones have position vectors, in metres after seconds,
(a) Show that the drones never collide.
(b) Show that their paths cross, and find the point where they do.
Step 1: (a) Equate the -components at the same time
gives , which is false for every .
A collision needs one value of that makes every component equal. The -components are never equal at the same time, so there is no such .
Step 2: (a) Conclude
At any time, drone is 2 m further along the direction than drone , so they never collide.
Step 3: (b) Use separate times
Solve : .
Step 4: (b) Solve two of the equations
The -equation gives . Then the -equation gives .
Step 5: (b) Check the third
: and . They agree, so the paths do cross.
In 3D, two equations fix and , and the third is a genuine test. If it failed, the paths would be skew and never cross.
Step 6: (b) Find the point
(and is the same).
Answer
(a) has no solution, so the -components are never equal at the same time and the drones never collide. (b) The paths cross at : drone is there at s and drone at s.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Collision: one time , every component equal.
Crossing: times and ; solve two components, check the third.
Substitute back to find the point, and state both times.
Watch out for
Using the same letter for both drones in part (b), which tests for a collision again.
Not checking the third component in three dimensions.