Lesson 5: Immigration, acculturation and culture shock
Interpret adjustment data and evaluate the U-curve
SkillsImmigration and acculturationAnalysing cross-cultural dataResearch methods across cultures
Worked example
Illustrative data: international students completed a homesickness and stress questionnaire (0–40; higher means more difficulty) on arrival and at 3, 6 and 12 months. The mean scores were 24, 21, 17 and 12.
(a) Describe the trend. (b) Explain whether the data support the U-curve model of culture shock. (c) Explain why this design is better than asking students at 12 months to recall how they felt.
Step 1: Describe the trend with numbers
Difficulty was highest on arrival (24) and fell at every measurement, to 12 at 12 months: a fall of 12 points, halving over the year.
Step 2: Compare with the U-curve
The U-curve predicts low difficulty in the honeymoon (high adjustment), rising to a peak in the crisis stage at around a few months, then falling. Here difficulty was highest at the start and fell steadily: no honeymoon and no later crisis. The data do not support the U-curve; they match Ward et al. (1998).
Difficulty scores are the reverse of adjustment, so a U in adjustment would be an upside-down U in difficulty.
Step 3: Explain the design advantage
This is a longitudinal design: the same students were measured as they went. Recall at 12 months would depend on memory, which is distorted by how students feel now, and would give one data point per student instead of four.
Answer
(a) Mean difficulty fell steadily from 24 on arrival to 12 at 12 months. (b) Not supported: the U-curve predicts low difficulty in a honeymoon then a later peak, but difficulty was highest on arrival. (c) Measuring the same students at each point avoids memory bias in recalling feelings and tracks change within each person.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Watch out for
Forgetting that a difficulty score runs the opposite way to adjustment.