Lesson 1: Sense of community
Evaluate an online group that lacks an element
SkillSense of community
Worked example
An online gaming group has 4,000 members. Anyone can join with one click. The two founders make every decision and delete posts that question them. Members share tips that help each other improve, and the group celebrates when members reach new ranks.
Use McMillan and Chavis's (1986) theory to explain why members may have only a weak sense of community, and suggest two changes that would strengthen it.
Step 1: Check membership
Anyone can join with one click, so the boundary is weak and joining needs no personal investment. With 4,000 members there is little identification with one another. Membership is weak.
Step 2: Check influence
The founders make every decision and remove disagreement. Members cannot influence the group, so influence runs one way only. Members are less likely to feel they matter.
Step 3: Check needs and connection
Sharing tips meets members' needs (integration and fulfilment of needs), and celebrating new ranks gives some shared positive events (shared emotional connection). These elements are present.
Step 4: Suggest changes linked to the missing elements
To strengthen membership: a short welcome process, a shared name or badge, and smaller teams within the group. To strengthen influence: let members vote on rules or elect moderators.
Each suggestion targets an element shown to be weak, which is what makes it a justified suggestion rather than a general idea.
Answer
Membership is weak (open boundary, no investment, too large to identify with) and influence is one-way (founders decide; dissent removed), so members may not feel they belong or matter, even though needs are met and there are some shared celebrations. A joining process with a shared badge and smaller teams would strengthen membership; voting on rules or electing moderators would give members influence.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Check each element in turn against the description.
Identify which are weak and explain the effect on the feeling of community.
Suggest changes that target the weak elements.