Lesson 7: Visual constancies and illusions
Explain the moon illusion with size constancy
SkillsConstancies and illusionsDepth cues
Worked example
The full moon looks much larger when it is just above the horizon than when it is high in the sky, although photographs show it makes the same-sized image in both places.
Use depth cues and size constancy to propose an explanation, and suggest one way to test it. (4 marks)
Step 1: The retinal image is unchanged
The moon is the same distance away in both positions, so it casts the same-sized retinal image. The difference must come from perception.
Step 2: Depth cues near the horizon
Near the horizon the moon is seen beyond trees, buildings and terrain. Interposition, linear perspective and texture gradient in the landscape tell the brain it is very far away. High in the empty sky there are no such cues.
Step 3: Apply size constancy
With size constancy, an object that makes the same retinal image but is perceived as further away is perceived as larger. So the horizon moon looks bigger: the same rule as the Ponzo illusion.
Step 4: Test it
Remove the depth cues: have participants view the horizon moon through a tube or a hole in a card (a reduction screen) and match its size. If the explanation is right, the illusion should shrink.
Answer
Depth cues in the landscape make the horizon moon seem further away than the moon overhead; size constancy then makes the same retinal image appear larger. Viewing the horizon moon through a tube, removing the cues, should reduce the illusion.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Rule out sensation: the retinal image is the same.
Name the depth cues present and the constancy that misapplies.
A test removes or adds the proposed cause.
Watch out for
Saying the atmosphere magnifies the moon. Photographs show the image is the same size.